Prognostication of Patients with COVID-19 Using Artificial Intelligence Based on Chest X-Rays and Clinical Data: a Retrospective Study.
Zhicheng Jiao,Ji Whae Choi,Kasey Halsey,Thi My Linh Tran,Ben Hsieh,Dongcui Wang,Feyisope Eweje,Robin Wang,Ken Chang,Jing Wu,Scott A. Collins,Thomas Y. Yi,Andrew T. Delworth,Tao Liu,Terrance T. Healey,Shaolei Lu,Jianxin Wang,Xue Feng,Michael K. Atalay,Li Yang,Michael Feldman,Paul J. L. Zhang,Wei-Hua Liao,Yong Fan,Harrison X. Bai
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/s2589-7500(21)00039-x
2021-01-01
Abstract:Background Chest x-ray is a relatively accessible, inexpensive, fast imaging modality that might be valuable in the prognostication of patients with COVID-19. We aimed to develop and evaluate an artificial intelligence system using chest x-rays and clinical data to predict disease severity and progression in patients with COVID-19. Methods We did a retrospective study in multiple hospitals in the University of Pennsylvania Health System in Philadelphia, PA, USA, and Brown University affiliated hospitals in Providence, RI, USA. Patients who presented to a hospital in the University of Pennsylvania Health System via the emergency department, with a diagnosis of COVID-19 confirmed by RT-PCR and with an available chest x-ray from their initial presentation or admission, were retrospectively identified and randomly divided into training, validation, and test sets (7:1:2). Using the chest x-rays as input to an EfficientNet deep neural network and clinical data, models were trained to predict the binary outcome of disease severity (ie, critical or noncritical). The deep-learning features extracted from the model and clinical data were used to build time-to-event models to predict the risk of disease progression. The models were externally tested on patients who presented to an independent multicentre institution, Brown University affiliated hospitals, and compared with severity scores provided by radiologists. Findings 1834 patients who presented via the University of Pennsylvania Health System between March 9 and July 20, 2020, were identified and assigned to the model training (n=1285), validation (n=183), or testing (n=366) sets. 475 patients who presented via the Brown University affiliated hospitals between March 1 and July 18, 2020, were identified for external testing of the models. When chest x-rays were added to clinical data for severity prediction, area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (ROC-AUC) increased from 0.821 (95% CI 0.796-0.828) to 0.846 (0.815-0.852; p<0.0001) on internal testing and 0.731 (0.712-0.738) to 0.792 (0.780-0 .803; p<0.0001) on external testing. When deep-learning features were added to clinical data for progression prediction, the concordance index (C-index) increased from 0.769 (0.755-0.786) to 0.805 (0.800-0.820; p<0.0001) on internal testing and 0.707 (0.695-0.729) to 0.752 (0.739-0.764; p<0.0001) on external testing. The image and clinical data combined model had significantly better prognostic performance than combined severity scores and clinical data on internal testing (C-index 0.805 vs 0.781; p=0.0002) and external testing (C-index 0.752 vs 0.715; p<0.0001). Interpretation In patients with COVID-19, artificial intelligence based on chest x-rays had better prognostic performance than clinical data or radiologist-derived severity scores. Using artificial intelligence, chest x-rays can augment clinical data in predicting the risk of progression to critical illness in patients with COVID-19. Copyright (C) 2021 The Author(s). Published by Elsevier Ltd. This is an Open Access article under the CC BY-NC-ND 4.0 license.