41 'Watch, thats amazing: an IPA and video study of dementia-care and crafting together
Rana,M.,Smith,J.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2024-ucl-qhrn2024.41
IF: 3.006
2024-04-04
BMJ Open
Abstract:Grieco's discussion about the importance of attending to 'areas of conflict between the clinician, the patient and the family in their views of illness' is relevant in contemporary critical dialogue about crisis, disruption and emergence in health and social care research (1996, p. 1). In the absence of a cure, the biomedical explanation of dementia influences informal caregivers' pre-interpreted world and beliefs about what someone diagnosed with dementia can and cannot do. Innovation is pivotal to knowledge-work and expertise underpinning the cure-system in clinical organisations (Williams, 2002). In contrast, the care-system operating in domestic homes, by families available and/or obligated to care, is less visible and rarely documented as the cure-system (Williams, 2002). Biomedical models and explanations of dementia situates expertise with health professionals, whereas qualitative researchers should walk alongside participants with lived experience of dementia to 'generate insights with them' (Cutcher, 2020, p. 314). As a critical inquiry into conditions and possibilities of being-in-the-world through crisis and disruption, this text and audio-visual paper presents findings from a PhD study, completed 2023, using interpretative phenomenological analysis and video data to elicit deep understandings of daughters' lived experience of crafting with their mother who has dementia. Video is used not only as an innovative adjunct to IPA's methodology, but to also privilege marginalised voices and domestic spaces where dementia care happens. As a creative methodology, videography fore-fronts a pre-reflective quality enabling daughters as study participants to stand 'inside their own experience' (Landy et al., 2012, p. 51) and do experiential knowledge-work 'on location' alongside the researcher (Rana & Hackney, 2018). Conflict stimulates innovation and change; it identifies issues for resolution – such as a need for a holistic 'knowing' (clinical and experiential) of dementia that integrates multiple expertise (learnt and lived) and reframes dementia-care as relational, reciprocal and regenerative.
medicine, general & internal