Peer Role-Play Simulation: A Valuable Alternative to Bedside Teaching During the COVID-19 Pandemic
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/AMEP.S399531
2023-03-23
Advances in Medical Education and Practice
Abstract:Abdelkhalig Hussein Elhilu, 1 Maged El-Setouhy, 2 Ali Sadeiq Mobarki, 2 Mohammed Maki Abualgasem, 2 Mohammed Ageel Ahmed 1 1 Department of Surgery, Faculty of Medicine, Jazan University, Jazan, Saudi Arabia; 2 Department of Family and Community Medicine, Faculty of Medicine, Jazan University, Jazan, Saudi Arabia Correspondence: Abdelkhalig Hussein Elhilu, Tel +966531514032, Email ; Purpose: The COVID-19 pandemic dramatically affected every aspect of life worldwide. Contact restrictions and social distancing during the epidemic has led to the suspension of bedside teaching (BST) and shifting to online didactic teaching and other methods of active learning. We implemented peer role-play simulation (PRPS) during the pandemic to compensate for the suspended BST. This study aims to explore the effectiveness of PRPS in developing the students' verbal communication, empathy and clinical reasoning skills compared to BST. Methods: This is a cross-sectional observational study conducted in Jazan University faculty of medicine with the study sample including all medical students enrolled in 5th and 6th year during the academic year 2020– 21. Data collection involved using a web-based validated questionnaire. Results: Most of the students (84.1%) rated bedside teaching (BST) as extremely beneficial or beneficial in developing verbal communication skills compared to 73.3% for peer role-play simulation (PRPS). A similar pattern was found in empathy skills development with 84.1% for bedside compared to 72.2% for PRPS. The pattern is reversed with the development of clinical reasoning skills with 77.7% rating BST as beneficial or extremely beneficial compared to 81.2% for PRPS. Conclusion: Overall, peer role-play is generally a valuable and trustworthy method in the absence of bedside teaching for enhancing clinical reasoning skills of medical students during the COVID-19 pandemic from students' perspective. It is less efficient than bedside teaching in enhancing communication skills. It cannot wholly replace bedside teaching, although it can be used reliably for that purpose in exceptional circumstances when bedside teaching cannot be implemented. Keywords: bedside teaching, clinical reasoning, empathy, medical education, peer role-play, verbal communication skills Reform initiatives in medical and health care education curricula during the previous decade have placed a strong emphasis on the use of technology and active learning in raising student engagement and developing their critical thinking abilities. 1 According to Bonwell and Elison, active learning is "anything that involves students in doing things and thinking about what they are doing". 2 Active learning strategies include simulations, demonstrations, experiments, debates, role-playing, small group discussions, creating visual representations and models, problem solving, research and presentations, case studies and games. 3 Peer role-playing is a simulation-based training method in which medical students take turns playing the roles of patient and clinician. 4 Kiger describes role-playing as an experiential learning strategy where students take on different roles in case scenarios and receive feedback to help them refine their skills. 5 Role-play training's instructional goal is to practice scenarios to help learners become more adept at handling similar problems in clinical practice. 6 It is a potent intervention that has the potential to improve learners' cognitive, psychomotor, and affective domains. 7 Learning in a real clinical setting, on the other hand, has numerous advantages. It concentrates on actual issues that arise in the course of professional practice. It is the only setting in which the abilities of taking a history, performing a physical examination, using clinical reasoning to make decisions, behaving empathetically, and being professional can be taught and acquired as a cohesive whole. 8 "Medicine is learned by the bedside not in the classroom" is one of the famous quotes of Sir William Osler. 9 Real patients provide the advantage of genuineness, according to students. 10 However, some studies noted a declining interest in bedside teaching. 11–13 One reason for this decline is that other methods of active learning have steadily crept into medical curricula at the expense of BST in the students' timetables. Other explanations for this drop include the rise in hospital patient turnover, perceived patient privacy violations, and a greater dependence on technology during the process of diagnosis. 14 The COVID-19 pandemic dramatically affected every aspect of life worldwid -Abstract Truncated-