Analysis of the Internal Relationship between Ecological Value and Economic Value Based on the Forest Resources in China

Jianxin Geng,Chengzhi Liang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/su13126795

IF: 3.9

2021-06-16

Sustainability

Abstract:In this study, we applied gross ecosystem product (GEP) theory in a case study to analyze and explain the natural resource asset value and ecosystem service value of forest resources in Jiaokou County, Shanxi Province, Northern China, in 2018. GEP refers to the total value of various final material products and services provided by ecosystems. In this paper, six service functions of a forest system, including water conservation, soil conservation, carbon fixation and oxygen release, forest nutrients, purification of atmospheric environment, and biodiversity, are valued by three calculation methods: the alternative cost method, market value method, and control cost method. The study revealed the following: (1) There is a parallel relationship between the value of natural resource assets and the value of ecosystem services. GEP includes the market value of natural resource assets, but it is mostly the value of ecosystem services. (2) The measurement of the physical quantity of forest ecosystem services depends on parameter data, and the monetary calculation often has no mature pricing basis, which leads to the large scale and uncertainty surrounding the evaluation results of ecosystem services. (3) The ecosystem service value and natural resource asset value have different practical significance, as well as alternate theoretical bases. The value of natural resource assets can be used as the asset valuation basis of economic transactions, which plays a role in macroeconomic management. The value of ecosystem services can be used as the basis of ecological compensation, providing information for the preparation of the balance sheet of natural resources.

environmental sciences,environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to analyze and interpret the internal relationship between the ecological value and economic value of forest resources, especially in the specific case of Jiaokou County in Shanxi Province in northern China. Specifically, the article explores the relationship between the value of natural resource assets and the value of ecosystem services, and attempts to answer the following questions:

1. **Should the same evaluation value be used for the ecological compensation mechanism and the natural resource balance sheet?**
2. **How to understand and interpret the value of natural resource assets and the value of ecosystem services?**

### Main research contents

1. **Theoretical framework**:
- Based on the Gross Ecosystem Product (GEP) theory, the article divides the ecosystem value into the value of natural resource assets and the value of ecosystem services.
- By comparing the System of National Accounts (SNA) and the System of Environmental - Economic Accounting (SEEA), it explores the application of these two international accounting standards in the natural balance sheet and the ecological compensation mechanism.

2. **Methodology**:
- The research adopts a variety of methods for data collection and analysis, including text surveys, phenomenon observations, semi - structured interviews, in - depth observations, and public data collection.
- A detailed survey of land types and areas in each village in Jiaokou County was carried out to accurately calculate the economic and ecological values of forest resources.
- Methods such as the replacement cost method, the market value method, and the prevention and control cost method were used to price forest ecosystem services.

3. **Case analysis**:
- Through the GEP assessment of forest resources in Jiaokou County, the article reveals the parallel relationship between the value of natural resource assets and the value of ecosystem services.
- The analysis shows that GEP includes not only the market value of natural resource assets, but more importantly, the value of ecosystem services.

### Key findings

1. **Different meanings of the value of natural resource assets and the value of ecosystem services**:
- The value of natural resource assets can be used as the basis for asset evaluation in economic transactions and for macro - economic management.
- The value of ecosystem services can be used as the basis for ecological compensation and provide information for the compilation of the natural resource balance sheet.

2. **Evaluation challenges**:
- The physical quantity measurement of forest ecosystem services depends on parameter data, while the monetization calculation often lacks a mature pricing basis, resulting in the uncertainty and large scale of the evaluation results.

Through these analyses, the article provides experience and reference for China's ecological protection practices, especially in the formulation of the ecological compensation mechanism and the natural resource balance sheet.