Abstract:Background: Across each state, the emergence of the COVID-19 pandemic in the United States was marked by policies and rhetoric that often corresponded to the political party in power. These diverging responses have sparked broad ongoing discussion about how the political leadership of a state may affect not only the COVID-19 case numbers in a given state but also the subjective individual experience of the pandemic. Objective: This study leverages state-level data from Google Search Trends and Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) daily case data to investigate the temporal relationship between increases in relative search volume for COVID-19 symptoms and corresponding increases in case data. I aimed to identify whether there are state-level differences in patterns of lag time across each of the 4 spikes in the data (RQ1) and whether the political climate in a given state is associated with these differences (RQ2). Methods: Using publicly available data from Google Trends and the CDC, linear mixed modeling was utilized to account for random state-level intercepts. Lag time was operationalized as number of days between a peak (a sustained increase before a sustained decline) in symptom search data and a corresponding spike in case data and was calculated manually for each of the 4 spikes in individual states. Google offers a data set that tracks the relative search incidence of more than 400 potential COVID-19 symptoms, which is normalized on a 0-100 scale. I used the CDC's definition of the 11 most common COVID-19 symptoms and created a single construct variable that operationalizes symptom searches. To measure political climate, I considered the proportion of 2020 Trump popular votes in a state as well as a dummy variable for the political party that controls the governorship and a continuous variable measuring proportional party control of federal Congressional representatives. Results: The strongest overall fit was for a linear mixed model that included proportion of 2020 Trump votes as the predictive variable of interest and included controls for mean daily cases and deaths as well as population. Additional political climate variables were discarded for lack of model fit. Findings indicated evidence that there are statistically significant differences in lag time by state but that no individual variable measuring political climate was a statistically significant predictor of these differences. Conclusions: Given that there will likely be future pandemics within this political climate, it is important to understand how political leadership affects perceptions of and corresponding responses to public health crises. Although this study did not fully model this relationship, I believe that future research can build on the state-level differences that I identified by approaching the analysis with a different theoretical model, method for calculating lag time, or level of geographic modeling.

Lag time between state-level policy interventions and change points in COVID-19 outcomes in the United States

Time lag effects of COVID-19 policies on transportation systems: A comparative study of New York City and Seattle

The Spatiotemporal Interaction Effect of COVID-19 Transmission in the United States

County-Level Social Distancing and Policy Impact in the United States: A Dynamical Systems Model

Spatial-temporal Analysis of COVID-19's Impact on Human Mobility: the Case of the United States

Tracking the Transmission Dynamics of COVID-19 with a Time-Varying Coefficient State-Space Model

Exploring the influence of human mobility factors and spread prediction on early COVID-19 in the USA

Dynamic Panel Data Modeling and Surveillance of COVID-19 in Metropolitan Areas in the United States: Longitudinal Trend Analysis

Hybrid Modeling of Regional COVID-19 Transmission Dynamics in the U.S

State-Level COVID-19 Symptom Searches and Case Data: Quantitative Analysis of Political Affiliation as a Predictor for Lag Time Using Google Trends and Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Data

Association mining based approach to analyze COVID-19 response and case growth in the United States

Causal Analysis of Health Interventions and Environments for Influencing the Spread of COVID-19 in the United States of America

Spatiotemporal effects of the causal factors on COVID-19 incidences in the contiguous United States

Which factors had the greatest impact on the United States COVID-19 outbreak? An ecological assessment of mitigation behavior and policy contributions to reducing SARS-CoV-2 transmission in the US from September 2020 through November 2021

Assessing COVID-19 risk with temporal indices and geographically weighted ordinal logistic regression in US counties

Impact of Interventional Policies Including Vaccine on Covid-19 Propagation and Socio-Economic Factors

Comparison of Predictive Models and Impact Assessment of Lockdown for COVID-19 over the United States

Non-pharmaceutical Interventions and COVID-19: Do County- and State-Level Policies Predict the Spread of COVID-19?

An Early Warning Approach to Monitor COVID-19 Activity with Multiple Digital Traces in Near Real-Time

Evolution of disease transmission during the COVID-19 pandemic: patterns and determinants

Time dynamics of COVID-19