Abstract:The latest maritime sulphur regulation poses a great challenge to effective enforcement issues. This study aims to achieve greater enforceability by proposing a novel self-reporting scheme, in which truthful reporting of non-compliance from the ship operator is certainly penalized with a smaller and ex-ante fine while falsified reporting of compliance is probabilistically penalized with a larger and ex-post fine as it has to be verified by the agency through random inspection. A simultaneous compliance game model is developed for the current enforcement scheme without self-reporting while a sequential game model is dedicated to self-reporting. Mixed strategy Nash equilibriums are derived separately to characterize the interactions between the agency's inspection strategy and ship operators' reporting strategy as well as complying strategy. Compared with the current scheme, it is demonstrated that self-reporting can always save some inspection costs as long as the current fine is between the smaller fine and the larger fine as specified in self-reporting. The savings come from the fact that the agency does not need to inspect some non-complying ship operators who report non-compliance. Moreover, the larger fine of falsified reporting acts as a stronger deterrent so that the inspection frequency can be decreased. In terms of total environmental cost (TEC) and total compliance cost (TCC), they cannot be decreased simultaneously. However, the total compliance rate can be improved together with TEC or TCC under certain conditions. Finally, self-reporting might decrease the total system cost without increasing the (total) penalty burdens perceived by (all) individual ship operators. The associated conditions are derived separately, allowing the policymakers to fine-tune the fine levels so that self-reporting can replace the current enforcement scheme and satisfy certain policy targets with higher acceptability from the stakeholders.

Agency Problems in Law Enforcement: Theory and Application to the U.S. Coast Guard

Strategic Naval Inspection for Port Safety and Security

Game Model for a New Inspection Regime of Port State Control under Different Reward and Punishment Conditions

Enforcement of law by the Port State Control (PSC)

Sensor Deployment for Pipeline Leakage Detection Via Optimal Boundary Control Strategies

Optimal Regulatory Enforcement

Contract Design With Safety Inspections

Enforcement of the global sulphur cap: Can self-reporting provide a better solution?

An Exploration of the Juxtaposition of Professional and Political Accountability in Local Law Enforcement Management

The Impact of Information Frictions Within Regulators: Evidence from Workplace Safety Violations

Political Accountability and the Distortion of Law Enforcement

Maritime Safety Management Strategy Based on Game Theory Analysis

Enforcing Regulation Under Illicit Adaptation

Nudging law enforcement: evidence from low priority initiatives

Structuring Bureaucratic Performance? Assessing the Policy Impact of Environmental Agency Design

Modeling Collusion-Proof Port Emission Regulation of Cargo-Handling Activities under Incomplete Information

How Effective Are Police? The Problem of Clearance Rates and Criminal Accountability

Contracts with Inspections

Corporate Governance Regulation Through Non-Prosecution

On the Use of Loose Monitoring and Lavish Pay in Agency

The institutional structure of pollution: large-scale externalities and the common law