Abstract:Slaughter sets the debate about what is acceptable to do to animals at an extremely low bar. Recently, there has been considerable investment in developing cell-based meat, an alternative meat production process that does not require the raising and slaughtering of animals, instead using muscle cells cultivated in a bioreactor. We discuss the animal ethics impacts of cell-based and plant-based meat on human-animal interactions from animal welfare and rights perspectives, focusing on industrial meat production scenarios. Our hypothesis is that the insertion of cell-based meat in the global meat market may alleviate farm animal suffering and potentially restore resources for wild fauna. We employed a conservative estimation of the cell-based meat contribution to the global meat market in the year 2040 to analyze the consequences for human-animal relationships for both wild animals and farmed domesticated animals. We discuss possible effects of an animal cell domestication process, previously described as the second domestication, on human-animal relationships. We consider its potential to reduce the impact of human demographic changes and land use on animal life, in particular whether there would be increased biomass availability and free land for wild animals. We anticipate a major reduction in animal suffering due to the decrease in the number of individual animals involved in food production, which justifies the adoption of cell-based meat from a utilitarian perspective. For the conventional animal food production that remains, further consideration is needed to understand which systems, either high or low welfare, will be retained and the impact of the innovation on the average farm animal welfare. Additionally, it seems likely that there will be less acceptance of the necessity of animal suffering in farming systems when meat production is uncoupled from animal raising and slaughter, supported by a deontological perspective of animal ethics. Consequent to this is anticipated the mitigation of relevant barriers to animal protection and to the recognition of animals as subjects by legislation. Thus, the development of the alternative meats may be related to a significant change in our relationship with non-human animals, with greater benefits than the prima facie effects on farm animals.

Dis/integrating animals: ethical dimensions of the genetic engineering of animals for human consumption

Animals in Moral Limbo: How Literary Pigs May Help Lab-Generated Ones

Public attitudes toward the use of technology to create new types of animals and animal products

Commodifying animals: ethical issues in genetic engineering of animals

Using animal history to inform current debates in gene editing farm animals: A systematic review

The Moral Imagination of De-extinction

Tainted Food and the Icarus Complex: Psychoanalysing Consumer Discontent from Oyster Middens to Oryx and Crake

Neurofeminism: Atwood Discusses Neurofeminist Issues of Consumerism and Cannibalism in the Edible Woman

Advances in Genetic Engineering of Domestic Animals

Posthuman Affirmative Business Ethics: Reimagining Human–Animal Relations Through Speculative Fiction

Applied Animal Ethics in Industrial Food Animal Production: Exploring the Role of the Veterinarian

Improvements in pig agriculture through gene editing

An Ecofeminist Politics of Chicken Ovulation: A Socio-Capitalist Model of Ability as Farmed Animal Impairment

Exploring the Theme of Human- Animal Kinship in Margaret Atwood’s Oryx and Crake

Omnivores Going Astray: A Review and New Synthesis of Abnormal Behavior in Pigs and Laying Hens

The Two Cultures Debate Revisited In The Posthumanist Age: Margaret Atwood'S Oryx And Crake As A Case Study

Uncoupling Meat From Animal Slaughter and Its Impacts on Human-Animal Relationships

Imagined futures for livestock gene editing: Public engagement in the Netherlands

Ethical Eggs: Can Synthetic Biology Disrupt the Global Egg Production Industry?

Genetic engineering at the heart of agroecology

Potential benefits of gene editing for the future of poultry farming