Cross-Language Priming in Chinese-English Bilinguals with Different Second Language Proficiency Levels.
Xiaowei Zhao,Ping Li,Youyi Liu,Xiaoping Fang,Hua Shu
2011-01-01
Abstract:Cross-Language Priming in Chinese-English Bilinguals with Different Second Language Proficiency Levels Xiaowei Zhao (zhaox@emmanuel.edu) Department of Psychology, Emmanuel College, 400 the Fenway, Boston, MA 01760 USA Ping Li (pul8@psu.edu) Department of Psychology, Pennsylvania State University University Park, PA 16802, USA Youyi Liu (youyiliu@bnu.edu.cn), Xiaoping Fang (pinson.fang@gmail.com), Hua Shu(shuhua@bnu.edu.cn) State Key Laboratory of Cognitive Neuroscience and Learning, Beijing Normal University Beijing 100875, China effects across languages, and have observed a number of interesting patterns, for example: (1) facilitation for translation equivalents is usually larger than that for semantically related words (Basnight-Brown & Altarriba, 2007); and (2) priming effects in the L1-L2 direction (from first language primes to second language targets) are often found stronger than those in the L2-L1 direction, which is referred to as “priming asymmetry” (Jiang & Foster, 2001). Although it is widely accepted that cross-language priming effects are real, the exact nature of this phenomenon has not been studied extensively or systematically, in particular with regard to the bilingual’s L2 proficiency from a development point of view. It might be possible to compare results from different studies with participants having varied L2 proficiency levels, but such comparisons must take into consideration the following: (1) different studies use very different experimental settings (see discussion of methodological issues in Altarriba & Basnight-Brown, 2007); and (2) the criteria used to measure participants’ L2 proficiency can be quite different. Some attempts have been made to study the development of priming effects across languages with similar writing scripts (i.e. English and Spanish; see Kiran & Lebel, 2007), but not much work has been done with bilinguals from languages of different writing systems (e.g., Chinese and English; but see a recent work of “semantic competitor priming” by Li & MacWhinney, in press). The current study aims at filling this gap. In particular, we first designed our experiment to control a host of variables which might have influences on priming (such as word length, frequency, relatedness proportion, nonword ratio, etc. Altarriba & Basnight-Brown, 2007; McNamara, 2005). We thenran a lexical decision task on three groups of Chinese- English bilinguals with different L2 (English) proficiency levels and learning history: low L2 proficiency, high L2 proficiency but without study abroad experience, and high L2 proficiency group with at least one year of experience living in US. We examined the priming effects from these three groups of participants with regard to a computational model of bilingual lexical organization. Abstract In this paper we describe an experimental study of cross- language priming effects between Chinese and English. The priming effects for both translation equivalents and semantically related word pairs were examined from a developmental aspect, in particular under three different situations according to bilinguals’ second language (English) proficiency level measured by CPVT and language history questionnaire, and learning experience determined by whether they have lived in a foreign country. The results match up with previous findings, in terms of the larger effects of priming from L1 to L2 than from L2 to L1 (“priming asymmetry”) and the stronger facilitation for translation priming than semantic priming. More importantly, our study demonstrates how such asymmetries in priming change as the bilinguals’ L2 learning history changes. These findings are discussed in light of current models of bilingual lexical memory. Keywords: Bilingualism; cross-language priming; Chinese. Introduction Cross-language priming is a widely used experimental paradigm in psycholinguistic research to study bilingual lexical representation and organization. . In this paradigm, cross-language word pairs (semantically related or translation equivalents) are presented to participants sequentially and participants are required to give a timed response (such as lexical decision or word naming). The method tests if bilinguals show response time differences to pairs of prime-target words that differ in their semantic relatedness. A faster reaction time to related pairs across languages (e.g., prime from the first language and target from the second language) is usually explained as a result of facilitation caused by the implicit spreading of activation from the prime word to the target word in bilinguals’ mental lexicon, which indicates that the bilingual’s two lexicons share a common conceptual memory representation (cf. Pavelnko, 2009). Many cross-language priming experiments have been conducted in the past decades (see a detailed review in Altarriba & Basnight-Brown, 2007). In most studies researchers have found translation and semantic priming