Abstract:Background: Pleural effusion is a fluid buildup in the pleural space that mostly result from congestive heart failure, bacterial pneumonia, malignancy, and pulmonary embolism. The diagnosis of this condition can be challenging as it presents symptoms that may overlap with other conditions; therefore, imaging diagnostic tools such as chest x-ray/radiograph (CXR), point-of-care ultrasound (POCUS), and computed tomography (CT) have been employed to make an accurate diagnosis. Although POCUS has high diagnostic accuracy, it is yet to be considered a first-line diagnostic tool as most physicians use radiography. Therefore, the current meta-analysis was designed to compare POCUS to chest radiography. Methods: n extended search for studies related to our topic was done on five electronic databases, including PubMed, Medline, Embase, Scopus, and Google Scholar. A quality assessment using the Quality Assessment of Diagnostic Accuracy Studies tool (QUADAS-2) was performed on all eligible articles obtained from the databases. Moreover, the diagnostic accuracy of POCUS and CXR was performed using STATA 16 software. Results: Our search yielded 1642 articles, of which only 18 were eligible for inclusion and analysis. The pooled analysis showed that POCUS had a higher diagnostic accuracy compared to CXR (94.54% (95% CI 91.74-97.34) vs. 67.68% (95% CI 58.29-77.08) and 97.88% (95% CI 95.77-99.99) vs. 85.30% (95% CI 80.06-90.54) sensitivity and specificity, respectively). A subgroup analysis based on the position of patients during examinations showed that POCUS carried out in supine and upright positions had higher specificity than other POCUS positions (99%). In comparison, lateral decubitus CXR had higher sensitivity (96%) and specificity (99%) than the other CXR positions. Further subgroup analyses demonstrated that CXR had higher specificity in studies that included more than 100 patients (92.74% (95% CI 85.41-100). Moreover, CXR tends to have a higher diagnostic accuracy when other CXR positions are used as reference tests (93.38% (95% CI 86.30-100) and 98.51% (95% CI 94.65-100) sensitivity and specificity, respectively). Conclusion: POCUS as an imaging modality has higher diagnostic accuracy than CXR in detecting pleural effusion. Moreover, the accuracy is still high even when performed by physicians with less POCUS training. Therefore, we suggest it is considered a first-line imaging tool for diagnosing pleural effusion at the patients' bedside.

The role of ultrasound in determining the amount of pleural effusion

Study on Distribution and Precise Quantification of Pleural Effusion in Mechanically Ventilated Patients

Development of a New Method to Measure Pleural Effusion Volume by Ultrasound in Critically Ill Patients

Comparing accuracy of bedside ultrasound examination with physical examination for detection of pleural effusion

Accuracy of Medical Students in Detecting Pleural Effusion Using Lung Ultrasound as an Adjunct to the Physical Examination

Application of ultrasound-guided medical thoracoscopy in patients with small amounts or without pleural effusion

Application value of ultrasound-guided intrathoracic drainage and real-time monitoring in treatment of subpulmonary effusion

Chest ultrasound is better than CT in identifying septated effusion of patients with pleural disease

Ultrasound for identifying pleural effusion aetiology: have you checked the ribs?

[Assessment of Positive End-Expiratory Pressure Induced Lung Volume Change by Ultrasound in Mechanically Ventilated Patients].

Value of conventional ultrasonography and contrast-enhanced ultrasonography in differential diagnosis of focal pleural thickening lesions

Rapid detection of pneumothorax by ultrasonography in patients with multiple trauma

Advancement in pleura effusion diagnosis: a systematic review and meta-analysis of point-of-care ultrasound versus radiographic thoracic imaging

Assessing the accuracy of pleural puncture sites in patients with pleural effusion as determined by clinical examination versus ultrasound—A single-centre prospective study

Role of chest ultrasound in management of exudative pleural effusion

Medical thoracoscope in diagnosis of large pleural effusion

Comparative Evaluation of Chest Ultrasonography and Computed Tomography as Predictors of Malignant Pleural Effusion: A Prospective Study

Precision of pleural puncture sites using thoracic ultrasound

Bedside Ultrasonography for Diagnosis of Pneumothorax.

[Evaluation of radiologic and echosonographic examinations in the detection and confirmation of pleural effusions]

A Quantitative Evaluation of Pleural Effusion on Computed Tomography Scans Using B-spline and Local Clustering Level Set.