Abstract:Many studies have documented discrepancies in student evaluation of teaching ratings between male and female instructors and between ethnic majority and minority instructors. Given the importance of such ratings to academic careers and the likelihood of potential intergroup bias, it is crucial that institutions consider approaches to mitigate such biases. Several recent studies have found that simple bias mitigation messaging can be effective in reducing gender and other biases. In the present research, students enrolled in several large Faculty of Science undergraduate courses at an Australian university were recruited on a volunteer basis via the course learning management system. Half of the participants were randomly assigned an intervention message highlighting potential biases relating to gender and language background. Data from 185 respondents were analysed using Bayesian ordinal regression models assessing the impact of message exposure on evaluation scores. Reading a bias intervention message caused students to significantly adjust their scores, with the nature of that change dependent on student and instructor characteristics. Among male students, the bias intervention message significantly increased scores for all except male instructors with English speaking backgrounds, for whom there was no significant impact of the message. In contrast, among female students, the bias intervention message significantly decreased scores for male instructors with English speaking backgrounds only. The sample showed an overall decrease in scores in the intervention group relative to the control group. This is the first study to detect a negative impact of bias intervention messaging on SET scores. Our results suggest students may not acknowledge their own potential bias towards instructors with whom they share similar demographic backgrounds. In conclusion, bias intervention messaging may be a simple method of mitigating bias, but it may lead to consequences in which one or more groups receive lower ratings as a result of the correction.

Teacher classroom interactions and behaviours: Indications of bias

Teacher bias matters: an integrative review of correlates, mechanisms, and consequences

Teacher bias in the virtual classroom

Quality and quantity: How contexts influence the emergence of teacher bias

Subtle discrimination: do stereotypes among teachers trigger bias in their expectations and widen ethnic achievement gaps?

Blatant and subtle prejudice, and the role of teachers in conveying tolerance and respect for the Other

Racial bias toward children in the early childhood education setting

Bias intervention messaging in student evaluations of teaching: The role of gendered perceptions of bias

Who you know influences where you go: Intergroup contact attenuates bias in trainee teachers' school preferences

The Role of Gender-Biased Perceptions in Teacher-Student Interaction

Teachers' Perceptions of Inappropriate Student Behavior as a Function of Teachers' and Students' Gender and Ethnic Background

Beyond students: how teacher psychology shapes educational inequality

Teachers’ Beliefs About Inclusive Education and Insights on What Contributes to Those Beliefs: a Meta-analytical Study

A Kindergarten Teacher Like Me

The Influence of Individual and Situational Factors on Teachers’ Justice Ratings of Classroom Interactions

Bidirectional associations between biased language exposure and school-based relationships across gender

The Short- and the Long-Run Impact of Gender-Biased Teachers

Standardized Patients' Perspectives on Bias in Student Encounters

Attitudes Toward Implicit Bias Among Athletic Trainers

The powerful impact of teacher expectations: a narrative review

The Brief Student–Teacher Classroom Interaction Observation