Abstract:The article proposes an account of the prevailing classical Chinese conception of reasoning and argumentation that grounds it in a semantic theory and epistemology centered on drawing distinctions (biàn ) between the similar and dissimilar kinds of things that do or do not fall within the extension of ‘names’ (míng ). The article presents two novel interpretive hypotheses. First, for pre-Hàn Chinese thinkers, the functional role associated with the logical copula is filled by a general notion of similarity or sameness (tóng ). Second, these thinkers’ basic explanation of reasoning is that it is a process of moving from a comparison of whether something is similar to a ‘model’ or ‘standard’ ( fǎ ) to a judgment about whether that thing is part of a certain kind (lèi ). Classical texts treat judgment as the attitude of predicating a ‘name’ of something, or, equivalently, of distinguishing whether something is the kind of thing denoted by a certain term. Reasoning is treated as a process of considering how some acts of term predication, or drawing distinctions, normatively commit one to making further, analogous predications or drawing further, analogous distinctions. Inference is thus understood as the act of distinguishing something as a certain kind of thing as a result of having distinguished it as similar to a relevant ‘model’ or ‘standard’. The article concludes by summarizing the consequences of the proposed account of early Chinese semantic and logical theories for the interpretation of other areas of classical Chinese thought.

A Glimpse of China’s Earliest Decision-Making: The Meaning of Zhēn 貞 ‘Test’ in the Huāyuánzhuāng East Oracular Inscriptions

The Interpretation of Disjunction in the Scope of Dou in Child Mandarin.

On the Meaning of Imperial Examination and Its Time of Origination

Review of: Adam C. Schwartz. The Oracle Bone Inscriptions from Huayuanzhuang East. Boston/Berlin: Walter de Gruyter Inc., 2019. Divinatory Inscriptions from the Eastern Sector of Huayuanzhuang in Yinxu

Rethinking the Demonization of China's Imperial Examination

The Tentative Explanation of the Four Pieces of Oracle Inscriptions Unearthed at the Relics of Zhougong Temple, Qishan, Shaanxi

Back to Divination Practice: Cross-Cultural Characteristics of Dunhuang Birdsong Divination Book IOLTibJ747

Omens and the Validity Constructing of Local Power:Research on Auspiciousness in Dunhuang during the Gui-yi-jun Period

The Chinese Origin of Xue (Learning)

The transmission of ritual related characters from the Shang to the Zhou: Taking Liao and Di as examples

Oracle Bone Inscriptions in Anyang City, China: Construction of Self-Identity and Utilizing Values Inherited from the Past

The Earliest “China”: The Concept of Zhongguo during the Xia, Shang, and Western Zhou Dynasties

Distinctions, Judgment, and Reasoning in Classical Chinese Thought

The Ritual Relics and the New Evidence of the Historian Recording Ancestry: The Sorcery-History Roots of Confucianism and Taoism from the Myth of YuGui

Diversity of form and meaning: A study of the evolution of the twelve zodiac signs between the Tang and Song dynasties

An Analysis on the First Half of the Inscriptions on the Lunar January Chime-bells of the Marquis Yu in Zeng State

Divination Studies in the Six Dynasties

Metamorphosis of a diplomatic interpreting event in ancient China

The Question of Pangxing and Xieshang in the “ Sandai shibiao ” ( Genealogical Tables of the Three Dynasties ) of the Shiji ( The Grand Clerk ’ s Records ) *

Trial Study of Newly-appeared Ban and Rongzhong Quadripod Dings

An Examination of the Liye No. 8-461 ‘Wooden Tablet of Nomenclature Changes’ and Its Implications for the Traditional View of the First Emperor’s (259–210 BCE) ‘Unification of Script’