Abstract:The metabolic energy rate of individual muscles is impossible to measure without invasive procedures. Prior studies have produced models to predict metabolic rates based on experimental observations of isolated muscle contraction from various species. Such models can provide reliable predictions of metabolic rates in humans if muscle properties and control are accurately modeled. This study aimed to examine how muscle-tendon model individualization and metabolic energy models influenced estimation of muscle-tendon states and time-series metabolic rates, to evaluate the agreement with empirical data, and to provide predictions of the metabolic rate of muscle groups and gait phases across walking speeds. Three-dimensional musculoskeletal simulations with prescribed kinematics and dynamics were performed. An optimal control formulation was used to compute muscle-tendon states with four levels of individualization, ranging from a scaled generic model and muscle controls based on minimal activations, inclusion of calibrated muscle passive forces, personalization of Achilles and quadriceps tendon stiffnesses, to finally informing muscle controls with electromyography. We computed metabolic rates based on existing models. Simulations with calibrated passive forces and personalized tendon stiffness most accurately estimate muscle excitations and fiber lengths. Interestingly, the inclusion of electromyography did not improve our estimates. The whole-body average metabolic cost was better estimated with a subset of metabolic energy models. We estimated metabolic rate peaks near early stance, pre-swing, and initial swing at all walking speeds. Plantarflexors accounted for the highest cost among muscle groups at the preferred speed and were similar to the cost of hip adductors and abductors combined. Also, the swing phase accounted for slightly more than one-quarter of the total cost in a gait cycle, and its relative cost decreased with walking speed. Our prediction might inform the design of assistive devices and rehabilitation treatment. The code and experimental data are available online. Simulations of the musculoskeletal system can provide insights into motion mechanics and energetics. To increase confidence in the approach, it is important to establish how predictions are affected by modelling assumptions. In this study, we evaluated how simulations with increasing levels of sophistication and metabolic energy models from the literature agreed with recorded muscle excitations, fiber lengths, and whole-body metabolic rates during walking at different speeds. We found that calibrating muscle passive components: muscle passive forces, and tendon stiffness, estimated better muscle excitations and fiber lengths than using original musculoskeletal model values. The metabolic energy cost of walking was closely estimated with only a subset of metabolic energy models. We estimated that the metabolic energy demands are the highest during three periods of the gait cycle—early stance, pre-swing, and initial swing, at all walking speeds. In all walking speeds, muscles that support plantarflexion accounted for the highest metabolic cost among all the muscle groups. As walking speed increases, the metabolic cost of the stance phase also increases. Our detailed description of metabolic costs at muscle groups and gait phases might help to design assistive devices and rehabilitation treatments.

Mechanical work as a (key) determinant of energy cost in human locomotion: recent findings and future directions

Biomechanical and physiological aspects of legged locomotion in humans

Mechanical and muscular factors affecting the efficiency of human movement

Soft tissue deformations explain most of the mechanical work variations of human walking

Mechanical energy costs of human movement: An approach to evaluating the transfer possibilities of two-joint muscles

The work to swing limbs in humans versus chimpanzees and its relation to the metabolic cost of walking

Greater foot and footwear mechanical work associated with less ankle joint work during running

The Effects of Upper-Body Exoskeletons on Human Metabolic Cost and Thermal Response during Work Tasks—A Systematic Review

Changes in mechanical work during neural adaptation to asymmetric locomotion

The exoskeleton expansion: improving walking and running economy

Mechanical and energetic consequences of reduced ankle plantar-flexion in human walking

Estimating the mechanical cost of transport in human walking with a simple kinematic data-driven mechanical model

Lower limb biomechanics of fully trained exoskeleton users reveal complex mechanisms behind the reductions in energy cost with human-in-the-loop optimization

Relationship between metabolic cost, muscle moments and co-contraction during walking and running

Insights into muscle metabolic energetics: Modelling muscle-tendon mechanics and metabolic rates during walking across speeds

Energy Flow and Functional Behavior of Individual Muscles at Different Speeds During Human Walking

The mechanisms and mechanical energy of human gait initiation from the lower-limb joint level perspective

Kinematic algorithm to determine the energy cost of running with changes of direction

Patterns of Selection of Human Movements IV: Energy Efficiency, Mechanical Advantage, and Asynchronous Arm-Cranking

A review of musculoskeletal modelling of human locomotion

Lower-Limb Prostheses and Exoskeletons With Energy Regeneration: Mechatronic Design and Optimization Review