On the distribution of the correlation coefficient when sampling from a mixture of two bivariate normal densities: Robustness and the effect of outliers

M. S. Srivastava,G. C. Lee
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/3315176
1984-06-01
Canadian Journal of Statistics
Abstract:Abstract The distribution of the sample correlation coefficient is derived when the population is a mixture of two bivariate normal distributions with zero mean but different covariances and mixing proportions 1 ‐ λ and λ respectively; λ will be called the proportion of contamination. The test of ρ = 0 based on Student's t , Fisher's z , arcsine, or Ruben's transformation is shown numerically to be nonrobust when λ, the proportion of contamination, lies between 0.05 and 0.50 and the contaminated population has 9 times the variance of the standard (bivariate normal) population. These tests are also sensitive to the presence of outliers. On dérive la distribution du coefficient de corrélation échantillonnal quand la population consistc en un mélange de deux distributions normales bivariées à moyenne zéro mais à covariances différentes, dans des proportions 1 ‐ λ et λ respectivement; λ représente la proportion de contamination. On demontre numériquement que le test de ρ = 0, basé sur les transformations t de Student, z de Fisher, arcsin, ou de Ruben, se révèle ětre non robuste quand λ, la proportion de contamination, se situe entre 0.05 et 0.50 et quand la variance de la population contaminée est neuf fois plus élevée que celle de la population normale bivariée. Ces tests détectent aussi la présence d'observations venant d'une distribution autre que la normale considérée.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?