Value Orientations, Religious Identity, and Career Decisions of Nursing Students in Japan

Sydney H. Croop,William Caudill,Jean L. Blumen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1097/00006199-196803000-00022

1968-03-01

Nursing Research

Abstract:In this presentation of data on value orientations of 113 students in two Japanese nursing schools, several principal findings emerged. First, value orientation associated with choice of nursing as a career was found to be statistically associated with formal religions Identification. Differential distributions of orientations within each group were in the direction hypothesised on the basis of assumptions concerning Idealism and pragmatism in Western Christianity and Oriental religions. However, when such variables as degree of reported religiosity, social status level of family orientation, and rural-urban origins were examined in relation to value orientation, no relationships were found within either the Christian or the Buddhist-Shinto group.Some Indications that the value orientations guided career decisions in other areas emerged through examination of reasons given for selection of a specialty In nursing. Idealism as a value was related to high patient orientation as a motivation for specialty choice. On the other hand, pragmatism did not appear to be related to level of patient orientation. Further, the factor of identification with a religious group was not related to the basis for specialty choice. Instead, the critical factor appeared to be value orientation rather than religious affiliation, Insofar as patient care orientation in specialty choice was concerned.In addition, some evidence regarding the professionalization process in the nursing schools was presented. While the pragmatic orientation of the traditional Japanese nurses did not differ by year, insofar as the value measure used here was concerned, this situation differed in the case of the Christian students. The fact that the Christian students in the third year appeared so similar in their recall to the Buddhist-Shinto students may possibly be an indication of a transition to a pragmatic, professional viewpoint Although these data have their limitations In view of: 1) the nature of the index, 2) the cross-sectional technique, and 3) the relatively limited sin of the study population, the findings are consistent with various other studies on the professionalization process.In addition, while casting light on the professionalization process in Institutional settings, the data reported here raised additional questions. The final products of the schools of nursing are mainly pragmatic in orientation. Looking at the differences between the Christian and Buddhist-Shinto students, It would appear that the former group may have a larger task In modifying original orientations than the latter as they pass through the process of becoming nurses In Japan. These findings may point up the differential congruence between initial values of students and the values of the professional role group to which they aspire. Since similar findings regarding the decline of Idealism In students in professional schools have been set forth in studies in American settings, such results lead to the question whether the requirements of professional education are such that initial idealism Is doomed to suffer regardless of the cultural context. More specifically, further cross-cultural research might center on the differing kinds of personal adaptations which professionalization requires and the effects these may have upon personality Integration, religio-ethical belief systems, and weltanscauungen of Individuals.

nursing