Vanity Fair and the Celestial City: Dissenting, Methodist, and Evangelical Literary Culture in England, 1720–1800 by Isabel Rivers (review)
Ioana Patuleanu
2022-10-18
Abstract:Rivers’s study of the printed materials disseminated by Protestant dissenters, Methodists, and Church of England evangelicals in the eighteenth century (1720–1800) is an encyclopedic work. This magnificent cornucopia of information on religious print explores with a fine comb and a magnifying glass several generations of British authors’ and printers’ labors of reaching out to a public whose desire for salvation they hoped to kindle and keep alive through reading matter. The overarching question that holds together the leviathan formed by these laborers in the field of faith stems from the paradox presented in The Pilgrim’s Progress. In Bunyan’s cultural landmark, which was explicitly intended to convert its audiences through story, the true Christian refuses to be embroiled in commercial transactions. Nevertheless, readers have to enter the marketplace and spend money to buy the book in order for it to communicate its message. Intrigued by this paradox, Rivers is interested in exploring the extent to which dissenting and evangelical print culture struggled with the difficulty of touching hearts while engaging with physical objects of various sizes and paper quality, many of them requiring readers first to touch their purses. The resulting story in three parts (“Books and their Readers,” “Sources,” and “Literary Kinds”) gives a comprehensive account of printers by denomination, publishers, and editorial decisions. What stand out are the moments of tacit acknowledgment of fellowship in an occasionally joint effort, despite denominational differences, to transform diverse audiences (the poor, families, educated individuals prone to grow cold in their faith) into pilgrims ready to pursue the Celestial City. Devotional writers put out abridged and rearranged Bibles with copious commentaries, sermons, prayers (in spite of early dissenters’ contempt for scripted prayer and preference for a spontaneous personal address to God), devotional handbooks, collections of lives, letters, diaries and journals, poems and hymns. One learns from Part I, “Books and their Readers,” who the major and minor printers were for each denomination, what was their output and how likely they were to engage with the books produced by other denominations. Rivers’s precise but charitable glance reveals that such moments of openness
History