Abstract:HSBC has come under sustained assault from a coordinated media campaign developed by the French newspaper Le Monde, in conjunction with the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists (ICIJ). The consortium involves contributions from and dissemination mechanisms in major media marketplaces, including Ireland, France, the United Kingdom and the United States. The investigation focuses on allegedly systemic attempts by HSBC Private Bank in Switzerland to drive business through the contracting around of bank secrecy laws. The revelations are problematic from both ethical and legal standpoints. First, the whistleblower was animated by greed rather than the public interest. Second, there is nothing either illegal or immoral in having a Swiss bank account. No ulterior motive can or should be asserted unless evidence to that effect is proffered. Relatedly, the disclosure of names without evidence of wrongdoing is an invasion of privacy. The practice also reverses the burden of proof, thus undermining the credibility of the ICIJ and its contributing partners. Thirdly, however, the nature of the HSBC response and the muted reaction of both the UK and US governments, highlight significant problems with the use and application of civil and criminal codes to financial institutions. The value of the HSBC dossier, therefore, rests less on its evidential power but rather on its capacity to influence the dynamics of regulatory reform. This article explores the multifaceted legal, ethical and regulatory issues, the manner in which accountability and due process can be undermined by careless reporting, and the implications for financial regulatory redesign.

The Sword of Damocles: who controls HSBC in the aftermath of its deferred prosecution agreement with the United States Department of Justice?

HSBC: will the sword of Damocles fall?

The Pretrial Agreement System of American Corporate Crime in the Perspective of Constitutionalism:Reviewing the Stein Case

What Are the Merits of Taking a Hybrid Regulatory Approach Toward the Enforcement of Corporate Financial Crime in the United Kingdom and United States of America?

The Depoliticization of Law in the News: BBC Reporting on US Use of Extraterritorial or 'Long-Arm' Law Against China

"One bank, two cultural identities": a case study of Chinese and British influence on the financial practices of HSBC bank

Prosecution Deferred, Prosecution Exempt: On the Interests of (In)Justice in the Non-Trial Resolution of Transnational Corporate Bribery

The failure of a global systemically important bank – Lessons for crisis management and resolution

Sovereign debt management and the globalization of finance: Recasting the City of London’s ‘Big Bang’

The Political Economy of Corporate Bribery: SNC-Lavalin Group as a Case Study

Domesticating Foreign Finance

Implied Representations in Derivative Transactions after Property Alliance Group Ltd v The Royal Bank of Scotland Plc

The Role of Central Counter-party Mechanism in OTC Derivatives Trading Regulation——Based on Huge Loss Event of JP Morgan Chase

Financial Crisis, Corporate Governance, and Bank Capital

Debts unravelled: trust law’s unbiased approach to resolving sovereign defaults

Central Counterparties in the OTC Derivatives Market from the Perspective of the Legal Theory of Finance, Financial Market Stability and the Public Good

Corporate Noncompliance: Do Corporate Violations Affect Bank Loan Contracting?

Innovation and deadlock in global financial governance: transatlantic coordination failure in OTC derivatives regulation

The unaccountable risks of LIBOR

Disequilibrium Between Regulation and Criminalization to Counter Financial Misconduct: the Case of Shadow Banking in China

Shareholder Litigation and Bank Risk