Assessing Ethical Climate: Adaptation and Psychometric Properties in the Indonesian Context
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/prbm.s462945
IF: 3.974
2024-06-07
Psychology Research and Behavior Management
Abstract:Mira Sekar Arumi, 1, 2 Marina Sulastiana, 1 Anissa Lestari Kadiyono, 1 Retno Hanggarani Ninin 1 1 Faculty of Psychology, Universitas Padjadjaran, Bandung, West Java, Indonesia; 2 Faculty of Psychology, Universitas Bhayangkara Jakarta Raya, Jakarta, Jakarta, Indonesia Correspondence: Marina Sulastiana, Universitas Padjadjaran, Jatinangor, West Java, 45363, Indonesia, Tel +6222-84288828, Email Background: Despite the importance of understanding ethical climates in Indonesian organizations, a standardized scale for measuring this is lacking. Therefore, this study aims to adapt, validate, and ensure the consistency of the Ethical Climate Questionnaire (ECQ) within Indonesia's cultural context. Methods: Data were collected from 565 Indonesian individuals aged 18 or older, using an online survey and convenience sampling. To ensure accurate measurements, Beaton's guidelines were followed. Reliability was assessed using Cronbach's alpha and McDonald's omega, while validity was examined through various analyses including content validity index and confirmatory factor analysis. Results: The Indonesian version of the ECQ measures egoist, benevolent, and principled ethical climates reliably (Cronbach's alpha: egoism=0.809, principle=0.920, benevolence=0.910). Validity analyses confirm the questionnaire's validity. Demographic analysis shows age impacts the principle dimension, while organizational type affects all dimensions. Conclusion: The Indonesian version of the ECQ demonstrates strong psychometric properties and cross-cultural adaptability, making it a valuable tool for assessing ethical climates among Indonesian individuals aged 18 or older. Keywords: ethical climate, Indonesian context, test validation, test adaptation Extensive scholarly research has emphasized the significance of organizational ethics in meeting stakeholder expectations and promoting sustainable business practices. However, despite this body of research, unethical conduct remains prevalent and continues to have detrimental effects on organizations and stakeholders. These effects encompass potential legal liabilities and revenue losses, 1 as well as the erosion of public goodwill. In order to gain a deeper comprehension of the factors contributing to unethical behavior, researchers have investigated various facets of the organizational context. This includes the role played by the ethical climate. 2,3 Research has consistently demonstrated that organizational climate plays a crucial role in influencing employee behavior. 4 Meta analysis by Kish-Gephart 5 revealed an organizations' ethical climate as a particularly relevant organizational factor explaining a wide range of unethical decisions of employees. Conceptually, ethical climate is categorized within the broader domain of organizational work climates, which has garnered significant attention in fields such as organizational behavior, sociology, and applied psychology. Ethical climate, as a subtype of work climate, can be best understood as a set of prescriptive climates that mirror the organizational procedures, policies, and practices with moral implications. These climates emerge when members believe that specific forms of ethical reasoning or behavior represent the expected standards or norms for decision-making within the organization. 6 According to a meta-analysis conducted by Martin and Cullen, 3 the findings suggest that the exploration of contextual or external effects has been somewhat limited, despite the potential significance of such factors. Cross-cultural research has already indicated variations in managerial ethical decision-making across different national contexts due to cultural and institutional influences. 7 Cullen et al 7 prompts a need to investigate what social and cultural drivers might be linked to the prevalence of various ethical climates in organizations within diverse countries and contexts. As ethical climate research using ethical climate theory expands globally, new challenges may arise. One such challenge is the limited adoption and usage of valid and reliable ethical climate questionnaires across different countries, including Indonesia. Indonesia, being a prominent developing country in Southeast Asia, grapples with corruption as a significant challenge, reflected in its 115th ranking among the world's most corrupt countries. 8 Therefore, assessing the ethical climate is vital for understanding workplace ethics in Indonesia and fostering efforts to implement strong ethics at both individual and organizational levels. It is not surprising that research in Indonesia addressing the topic of ethical climate has e -Abstract Truncated-
psychology, clinical, multidisciplinary