Abstract:While anecdotes suggest that workplace gender disparities widely exist, the current literature on this topic has not provided sufficient causal evidence due to two deficiencies. First, because most gender studies rely on surveys and laboratory experiments, causal evidence of gender disparities in the field is rare; Second, because most empirical gender studies focus on individual workers or C-suite executives, research on low-level managers using real-world personnel data is also rare. In this study, we aim to address these deficiencies by empirically studying the effect of gender on the job assignment of frontline managers in a large sportswear retail chain using personnel, sales, and operational data. Our estimation strategy is a two-step fixed effects panel estimation framework, which 1) separately identifies manager fixed effects and store fixed effects by exploring manager switches across stores; and 2) estimates the effect of gender on store-manager assignment while controlling for the estimated manager fixed effects from the first step. This framework allows us to uncover causal evidence for the existence of gender bias in store-manager assignment—male managers were more likely than their female counterparts to be assigned to stores with higher sales potential, i.e., core stores, stores with a higher sales target, or stores with a larger number of sales clerks. To support this finding, we test three alternative hypotheses. First, we find that male managers achieved similar store sales when replacing their female counterparts in the same stores and vice versa, and male managers were not better at managing the turnover of sales clerks, neither of which supports an alternative hypothesis of differential managerial abilities; Second, we conduct a maximum likelihood estimation of a discrete-time Markov chain that models the processes of store-manager assignment and manager turnover, and do not find evidence to support the hypothesis that the observed gender inequity in store-manager assignment is driven by different gender preferences to leave stores with low sales potential. Third, we find that male sales clerks or male store managers on average made similar individual sales as their female counterparts, thereby not supporting a career selection bias hypothesis that men working at this retailer on average have higher sales abilities than women. Translating our findings into an actionable insight, we develop a gender inequity index (GII) to help organizations measure potential gender bias in job assignment. Applying this index to a simulation study using the retailer’s manager compensation data, we demonstrate the implications of gender-biased job assignment on the gender pay gap.

At Sam's Club, no girls allowed: the lived experience of sex discrimination

Hidden in Plain Sight For Too Long: Using Text Mining Techniques to Shine a Light on Workplace Sexism and Sexual Harassment

Why Do Women Struggle to Climb the Corporate Ladder? Evidence from Retail Frontline Managers

Robbing a Barren Vault: The Implications of Dukes v. Wal-Mart for Cases Challenging Subjective Employment Practices

Discrimination against Working Women and Its Impact on Their Work Performance in District Sahiwal

Giving Women the Benefit of the Doubt? Examining Gender Differences in Schools' Management of Sexual Allegations Against Employees

Workplace Sexual Harassment and Vulnerabilities among Low-Wage Hispanic Women

“Try Not to Make Waves”: Managing Gender Discrimination in Outdoor Recreation

Women's experiences of sexual harassment in the retail clothing industry: a grounded theory study

Sex, gender and work segregation in the cultural industries

Gender differences in the work commitment of Chinese workers: An investigation of two alternative explanations

Gender Discrimination Among Academic Physicians

Ladies first? A field study of discrimination in coffee shops

Perceiving Discrimination: Race, Gender, and Sexual Orientation in the Legal Workplace

Combatting gender discrimination: A lack of fit framework

Do Women Choose Different Jobs from Men? Mechanisms of Application Segregation in the Market for Managerial Workers

Gender discrimination among women healthcare workers during the COVID-19 pandemic: Findings from a mixed methods study

What's Sex Got To Do With Fair Machine Learning?

A Study on Gender Discrimination

Sex differences in perceived discrimination among patients with obesity

Understanding Labor Market Discrimination Against Transgender People: Evidence from a Double List Experiment and a Survey