Abstract:It is necessary to measure the mixing states of light-absorbing carbon (LAC) particles to reduce uncertainties in climate forcing due to particulate from wildfires and biomass combustion. For refractory LAC (normally called refractory black carbon; rBC), such measurements can be made using the single particle soot photometer (SP2). The SP2 measures the incandescent mass of individual particles heated by a 1064 nm laser. The SP2 also monitors single-particle light scattering from rBC plus internally mixed material (e.g., coatings of volatile particulate matter). rBC mixing states can be estimated from SP2 measurements by combining the scattering and incandescence signals. This is the basis of the published methods known as (i) scattering–incandescence lag-time, (ii) leading-edge only (LEO), and (iii) normalized derivative methods. More recently, the tandem centrifugal particle mass analyzer–single particle soot photometer (CPMA-SP2) method has been developed. The CPMA-SP2 method does not rely on the SP2 scattering signals and, therefore truly measures the rBC mass fraction, with no assumptions regarding particle composition or morphology. In this study, we provide the first quantitative comparison of the light-scattering and CPMA-SP2 methods for measuring mixing state. We discuss the upper and lower limits of detection (in terms of both rBC and coatings), temporal resolution, role of counting statistics, and errors associated with the measurements. We use a data set of atmospheric particles sampled at a regional background site (Kamloops about 350 km northeast of Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada), where the majority of rBC was emitted by seasonal wildfires. In the overall comparison of measurement methods, the CPMA-SP2 method is found to have significantly better systematic uncertainties than the light-scattering methods for wildfire smoke. For example, the light-scattering methods could not quantify coatings on half of the rBC particles, because their light-scattering signals were below the SP2 detection limit. Consequently, the bias in SP2-only estimates of rBC mixing states depends on the size distribution of the rBC particles. Although more accurate, CPMA-SP2 measurements require significantly more time to acquire, whereas SP2-only light-scattering analyses (both LEO and lag-time) can provide near real-time qualitative information representing large rBC particles.

A Novel Method for Estimating Light-Scattering Properties of Soot Aerosols Using a Modified Single-Particle Soot Photometer

Relating the single particle soot photometer (SP2) signal response to soot maturity

Comparison of the LEO and CPMA-SP2 techniques for black-carbon mixing-state measurements

Research on the Light Scattering Property of Fractal Soot Particles

An optical soot sizing method without prior morphology parameters

Physical and chemical characterization of urban aerosol particles through Soot Particle Aerosol Mass Spectrometry

150 Keynote: A New Aerosol Mass-Spectrometer for Simultaneous Detection of Health-Relevant Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons, Soot and Inorganic Components from Individual Airborne Particles

Development and validation of a multi-angle light scattering method for fast engine soot mass and size measurements

Aerosol Measurements by Soot Particle Aerosol Mass Spectrometer: a Review

Light Scattering Intensity Field Imaging Sensor for In Situ Aerosol Analysis

Size-Resolved Single-Particle Fluorescence Spectrometer for Real-Time Analysis of Bioaerosols: Laboratory Evaluation and Atmospheric Measurements

Determination of Soot Particle Size Using Time-Gated Laser-Induced Incandescence Images

Numerical investigation on measurement errors of mixing states of fractal black carbon aerosols using single-particle soot photometer and the effects on radiative forcing estimation

Complex Aerosol Characterization by Scanning Electron Microscopy Coupled with Energy Dispersive X-ray Spectroscopy

Differentiation of Soot Particulates in Air Using Polarized Light Scattering Method.

Relative errors in derived multi-wavelength intensive aerosol optical properties using cavity attenuated phase shift single-scattering albedo monitors, a nephelometer, and tricolour absorption photometer measurements

Characterization of Particle Shape with an Improved 3D Light Scattering Sensor (3D-LSS) for Aerosols

Multiparametric optical characterization of airborne dust with single particle extinction and scattering

Numerical investigation on retrieval errors of mixing states of fractal black carbon aerosols using single-particle soot photometer based on Mie scattering and the effects on radiative forcing estimation

Method to Measure the Size-Resolved Real Part of Aerosol Refractive Index Using Differential Mobility Analyzer in Tandem with Single-Particle Soot Photometer

A novel light scattering method with size analysis and correction for on-line measurement of particulate matter concentration