Understanding dual process cognition via the minimum description length principle
Ted Moskovitz,Kevin J. Miller,Maneesh Sahani,Matthew M. Botvinick
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pcbi.1012383
2024-10-19
PLoS Computational Biology
Abstract:Dual-process theories play a central role in both psychology and neuroscience, figuring prominently in domains ranging from executive control to reward-based learning to judgment and decision making. In each of these domains, two mechanisms appear to operate concurrently, one relatively high in computational complexity, the other relatively simple. Why is neural information processing organized in this way? We propose an answer to this question based on the notion of compression. The key insight is that dual-process structure can enhance adaptive behavior by allowing an agent to minimize the description length of its own behavior. We apply a single model based on this observation to findings from research on executive control, reward-based learning, and judgment and decision making, showing that seemingly diverse dual-process phenomena can be understood as domain-specific consequences of a single underlying set of computational principles. Since the founding of psychology as a scientific discipline, scientists have recognized that much of human and animal behavior falls into two separate categories: slow, effortful deliberation (e.g., solving math problems) and fast, automatic habitual action selection (e.g., signing your name). Such "dual process" theories of cognition have since been developed to explain a number of phenomena from across psychology and neuroscience. Despite all of these experimental results, understanding why this pattern in behavior exists has proven elusive. In this work, we develop a model of dual process cognition which can be derived independently from experimental observations about the brain. Our theory proposes that the division between effortful and automatic behavior emerges as a natural result of the need to balance mastery of the tasks we have to complete every day and flexibility to adapt to new circumstances. In a large number of computer simulations, our model captures many behavioral phenomena associated with "dual process" cognition across multiple subfields of cognitive science.
biochemical research methods,mathematical & computational biology