Abstract:Gratitude shapes individuals' behaviours and impacts the harmony of society. Many previous studies focused on its association with prosocial behaviours. A possibility that gratitude can lead to moral violation has been overlooked until recently. Nevertheless, the neurocognitive mechanisms of gratitude-induced moral violation are still unclear. On the other hand, though neural correlates of the gratitude's formation have been examined, the neural underpinnings of gratitude-induced behaviour remain unknown. For addressing these two overlapped research gaps, we developed novel tasks to investigate how participants who had received voluntary (Gratitude group) or involuntary help (Control group) punished their benefactors' unfairness with functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI). The Gratitude group punished their benefactors less than the Control group. The self-report and computational modelling results demonstrated a crucial role of the boosted protection tendency on behalf of benefactors in the gratitude-induced injustice. The fMRI results showed that activities in the regions associated with mentalizing (temporoparietal junction) and reward processing (ventral medial prefrontal cortex) differed between the groups and were related to the gratitude-induced injustice. They suggest that grateful individuals concern for benefactors' benefits, value chances to interact with benefactors, and refrain from action that perturbs relationship-building (i.e., exert less punishment on benefactors' unfairness), which reveal a dark side of gratitude and enrich the gratitude theory (i.e., the find-bind-remind theory). Our findings provide psychological, computational, and neural accounts of the gratitude-induced behaviour and further the understanding of the nature of gratitude.

Feeling the intangible: antecedents of gratitude toward intangible benefactors

Neural Responses to Intention and Benefit Appraisal Are Critical in Distinguishing Gratitude and Joy.

Putting the “You” in “Thank You”

From gratitude to injustice: Neurocomputational mechanisms of gratitude-induced injustice

Culturally Divergent Consequences of Receiving Thanks in Close Relationships.

Warm thanks: Gratitude expression facilitates social affiliation in new relationships via perceived warmth.

Nostalgia: The gift that keeps on giving

Epistemic gratitude and the provision of information

Benefactor intention, perceived helpfulness, and personal responsibility influence gratitude and indebtedness

The Benefits of Receiving Gratitude for Helpers: A Daily Investigation of Proactive and Reactive Helping at Work

Gratitude predicts selective moral concern about interpersonal harms

Thanks for Everything: A Quasi-Experimental Examination of Gratitude in Organizations

The grateful disposition: A conceptual and empirical topography.

Association of Gratitude With Individual and Organizational Outcomes Among Volunteers: An Application of Broaden-and-Build Theory of Positive Emotions

The psychological mechanism of internet altruistic behavior transmission: a givers and recipients perspective

Beneficiaries or Charity: The Influence of the Source of Acknowledgments

The social functions of the emotion of gratitude via expression.

Perception of helper's autonomous motivation increases recipient's prosocial behaviour intentions via feelings of gratitude

Cognitive-affective structure of gratitude and its relationships with subjective well-being

Thanks Be to God: Divine Gratitude and Its Relationship to Well-Being

Appreciating social science research on gratitude: An integrative review for organizational scholarship on gratitude in the workplace