Abstract:Most of the information security management research involving fear appeals is guided by either protection motivation theory or the extended parallel processing model . Over time, extant research has extended these theories, as well as their derivative theories, in a variety of ways, leading to several theoretical and empirical inconsistencies. The large body of fragmented, and sometimes conflicting, research has muddied the broader understanding of what drives protection- and defensive motivation. We provide guidance to the security discourse by offering the first study in the literature to employ two-stage meta-analytic structural equation modeling (TSSEM), which combines covariance-based structural equation modeling and meta-analysis. Information systems (IS) researchers have traditionally used meta-analysis for structural equation modeling for such purposes—an approach that has several serious statistical flaws. Using 341 systematically selected empirical security articles (representing 383 unique studies) and TSSEM, we pool a large series of five datasets to test six models, from which we examine the effects of constructs and paths in the security fear-appeals literature. We compare and test six versions of models inspired by issues in the broader fear-appeals literature. We confirm the importance of both the threat- and coping-appraisal processes; establish the central role of fear and that it has greater importance than threat; show that efficacy is a stronger predictor of protection motivation than is threat; demonstrate that response costs as currently measured are ineffective but that maladaptive rewards have a strong negative effect on protection motivation and a positive effect on defensive motivation; and provide evidence that dual models of danger control and fear control should be used.

The Impact of Vulnerability to and Severity of a Health Risk on Processing and Acceptance of Fear-Arousing Communications: A Meta-Analysis

Threatening communication: a critical re-analysis and a revised meta-analytic test of fear appeal theory

A Meta-Analysis of Fear Appeals: Implications for Effective Public Health Campaigns

Appealing to fear: A meta-analysis of fear appeal effectiveness and theories.

Sixty years of fear appeal research: current state of the evidence

Examining the Differential Effectiveness of Fear Appeals in Information Security Management Using Two-Stage Meta-Analysis

Danger and Fear Control in Response to Fear Appeals: The Role of Need for Cognition

Self- and Response Efficacy Information in Fear Appeals: A Meta-Analysis

Putting the fear back into fear appeals: The extended parallel process model

Negative Outcomes, Threats and Threat Appeals: Widening the Conceptual Framework for the Study of Fear and Other Emotions in Social Marketing Communications

An Investigation of Cognitive Processing of Fear Appeal Messages Promoting HPV Vaccination: Predictors and Outcomes of Magnitude and Valence of Cognitive Responses

Fear-Appeal Messages: Message Processing and Affective Attitudes

Threat Appraisal, Emotional Contagion, and Fear of COVID-19: Revision of the Extended Parallel Process Model

Message Effectiveness of Fear Appeals in Vaccination Communication Campaigns: A Systematic Review

Understanding the Design of Fear Appeals by Applying the Extended Parallel Process Model: A Qualitative Analysis of COVID-19 Public Service Announcements

Unmasking the pivotal role of ad–target ethnic congruence in driving consumers' response to fear appeals

Does perceived risk influence the effects of message framing? Revisiting the link between prospect theory and message framing

Reconsidering the Effectiveness of Fear Appeals: An Experimental Study of Interactive Fear Messaging to Promote Positive Actions on Climate Change

Mechanisms of Climate Change Media Effects: Roles of Risk Perception, Negative Emotion, and Efficacy Beliefs

Effects of Fear and Humor Appeals in Public Service Announcements (PSAs) on Intentions to Purchase Medications via Social Media

Effects of Prosocial and Hope-Promoting Communication Strategies on COVID-19 Worry and Intentions for Risk-Reducing Behaviors and Vaccination: Experimental Study