Practical Forestry

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/057292c0

IF: 64.8

1898-01-01

Nature

Abstract:No doubt a forester might gain some advantage from a perusal of this book, provided he read it with caution. But he would encounter several statements with which he would have a difficulty in agreeing. For instance, the author deliberately says, “To purchase trees, or to plant by contract, are also means to ensure failure.” If that were true, it would be small wonder that the results of forestry are not in all cases satisfactory in England, where quite 90 per cent, of the plantations have been formed in the ways that the book condemns. A most serious slip occurs in the statement of the rule for ascertaining the cubical contents of a tree, where “square of the girth” appears instead of “square of the quarter girth.” This would not mislead a practical man, but it might lead to most unpleasant consequences in the case of a student who made use of the book in preparing for an examination.

multidisciplinary sciences