Abstract:Choosing a suitable process-oriented eco-hydrological model is essential for obtaining reliable simulations of hydrological processes. Determining soil hydraulic and solute transport parameters is another fundamental prerequisite. Research discussing the impact of considering evaporation fractionation on parameter estimation and practical applications of isotope transport models is limited. In this study, we analyzed parameter estimation results for two datasets for humid and arid conditions using the isotope transport model in HYDRUS-1D, in which we either did or did not consider fractionation. The global sensitivity analysis using the Morris and Sobol’ methods and the parameter estimation using the Particle Swarm Optimization algorithm highlight the significant impact of considering evaporation fractionation on inverse modeling. The Kling-Gupta efficiency (KGE) index for isotope data can increase by 0.09 and 1.49 for the humid and arid datasets, respectively, when selecting suitable fractionation scenarios. Differences in estimated parameters propagate into the results of two practical applications of stable isotope tracing: i) the assessment of root water uptake (RWU) and drainage travel times (i.e., the time elapsed between water entering the soil profile as precipitation and leaving it as transpiration or drainage) in the lysimeter (humid conditions) and ii) evaporation estimation in a controlled experimental soil column (arid conditions). The peak displacement method with optimized longitudinal dispersivity provides much lower travel times than those obtained using the particle tracking algorithm in HYDRUS-1D. Considering evaporation fractionation using the Craig-Gordon (CG) and Gonfiantini models is likely to result in estimates of older water ages for RWU than the no fractionation scenario. The isotope mass balance method that uses the isotopic composition profile simulated by HYDRUS-1D while considering fractionation using the CG and Gonfiantini models, or the measured evaporation isotope flux, provides comparable results in evaporation estimation as the HYDRUS-1D water mass balance method and direct laboratory measurements. In contrast, the no fractionation scenario reasonably estimates evaporation only when using the HYDRUS-1D water mass balance method. The direct use of simulated isotopic compositions in the no fractionation scenario may result in large biases in practical applications in the arid zone where evaporation fractionation is more extensive than in humid areas.

The isotopic composition of evaporating waters – review of the historical evolution leading up to the Craig–Gordon model

Isotope effects in the evaporation of water: a status report of the Craig-Gordon model

Short term evaporation estimation in a natural semiarid environment: New perspective of the Craig – Gordon isotopic model

Craig–Gordon model validation using stable isotope ratios in water vapor over the Southern Ocean

An Improved Craig–Gordon Isotopic Model: Accounting for Transpiration Effects on the Isotopic Composition of Residual Water during Evapotranspiration

Non‐Equilibrium Fractionation Factors for D/H and 18O/16O During Oceanic Evaporation in the North‐West Atlantic Region

Craig-Gordon model validation using observed meteorological parameters and measured stable isotope ratios in water vapor over the Southern Ocean

Influence of Condensate Evaporation on Water Vapor and Its Stable Isotopes in A Gcm

Stable isotopes in atmospheric water vapor and applications to the hydrologic cycle

The impact of evaporation fractionation on the inverse estimation of soil hydraulic and isotope transport parameters

The evolution of 17O-excess in surface water of the arid environment during recharge and evaporation

Rebuilding the theory of isotope fractionation for evaporation of silicate melts under vacuum condition

Modeling Atmospheric Stable Water Isotopes and the Potential for Constraining Cloud Processes and Stratosphere‐troposphere Water Exchange

Tracing the sources and evaporation fate of surface water and groundwater using stable isotopes of hydrogen and oxygen

Hydrologic implications of the isotopic kinetic fractionation of open-water evaporation

Modeling the dynamic behavior of a droplet evaporation device for the delivery of isotopically calibrated low-humidity water vapor

Calculation of Kinetic Fractionation of Open‐Water Evaporation Over an Upland Reservoir

A Surface-Specific Isotope Effect in Mixtures of Light and Heavy Water

Isotopic kinetic fractionation of evaporation from small water bodies

Suspended in sound: New constraints on isotopic fractionation of falling hydrometeors using acoustically levitated water droplets

Unraveling quantum mechanical effects in water using isotopic fractionation