Abstract:BACKGROUND: There is increasing recognition that supermarkets are an important environment for health-promoting interventions such as fiscal food policies or front-of-pack nutrition labeling. However, due to the complexities of undertaking such research in the real world, well-designed randomized controlled trials on these kinds of interventions are lacking. The Virtual Supermarket is a 3-dimensional computerized research environment designed to enable experimental studies in a supermarket setting without the complexity or costs normally associated with undertaking such research.OBJECTIVE: The primary objective was to validate the Virtual Supermarket by comparing virtual and real-life food purchasing behavior. A secondary objective was to obtain participant feedback on perceived sense of "presence" (the subjective experience of being in one place or environment even if physically located in another) in the Virtual Supermarket.METHODS: Eligible main household shoppers (New Zealand adults aged ≥18 years) were asked to conduct 3 shopping occasions in the Virtual Supermarket over 3 consecutive weeks, complete the validated Presence Questionnaire Items Stems, and collect their real supermarket grocery till receipts for that same period. Proportional expenditure (NZ$) and the proportion of products purchased over 18 major food groups were compared between the virtual and real supermarkets. Data were analyzed using repeated measures mixed models.RESULTS: A total of 123 participants consented to take part in the study. In total, 69.9% (86/123) completed 1 shop in the Virtual Supermarket, 64.2% (79/123) completed 2 shops, 60.2% (74/123) completed 3 shops, and 48.8% (60/123) returned their real supermarket till receipts. The 4 food groups with the highest relative expenditures were the same for the virtual and real supermarkets: fresh fruit and vegetables (virtual estimate: 14.3%; real: 17.4%), bread and bakery (virtual: 10.0%; real: 8.2%), dairy (virtual: 19.1%; real: 12.6%), and meat and fish (virtual: 16.5%; real: 16.8%). Significant differences in proportional expenditures were observed for 6 food groups, with largest differences (virtual - real) for dairy (in expenditure 6.5%, P<.001; in items 2.2%, P=.04) and fresh fruit and vegetables (in expenditure: -3.1%, P=.04; in items: 5.9%, P=.002). There was no trend of overspending in the Virtual Supermarket and participants experienced a medium-to-high presence (88%, 73/83 scored medium; 8%, 7/83 scored high).CONCLUSIONS: Shopping patterns in the Virtual Supermarket were comparable to those in real life. Overall, the Virtual Supermarket is a valid tool to measure food purchasing behavior. Nevertheless, it is important to improve the functionality of some food categories, in particular fruit and vegetables and dairy. The results of this validation will assist in making further improvements to the software and with optimization of the internal and external validity of this innovative methodology.

Stimulating Sustainable Food Choices Using Virtual Reality: Taking an Environmental vs Health Communication Perspective on Enhancing Response Efficacy Beliefs

A randomized trial testing the effectiveness of virtual reality as a tool for pro-environmental dietary change

Virtual reality facilitates pro-environmental behavioural intentions

Immersive virtual reality helps to promote pro-environmental norms, attitudes and behavioural strategies

Virtual Environment, Real Impacts: A Self-determination Perspective on the use of Virtual Reality for Pro-environmental Behavior Interventions

Exploring the Interplay of Pro-Environmental Attitudes, Dietary Choices, and Packaging Preferences: A Virtual Reality Restaurant Scenario Study

Observing the earth from space: Does a virtual reality overview effect experience increase pro-environmental behaviour?

Can Product Information Steer towards Sustainable and Healthy Food Choices? A Pilot Study in an Online Supermarket

Using VR for Science Communication: Presence, Message Perception, and Pro-Environmental Effects

The effect of virtual reality technology and education on sustainable behavior: a comparative quasi-experimental study

Immersive Storytelling for Pro-Environmental Behaviour Change: The Green Planet Augmented Reality Experience

Author Response for "making Choices of Food and Non‐food Products: a Comparison Between Virtual Stores and Online Shopping"

Mastery experiences in immersive virtual reality promote pro-environmental waste-sorting behavior

The virtual supermarket: an innovative research tool to study consumer food purchasing behaviour

Increasing awareness of climate change with immersive virtual reality

Using a 3D Virtual Supermarket to Measure Food Purchase Behavior: A Validation Study

Looking Into a Future Which Hopefully Will Not Become Reality: How Computer Graphics Can Impact Our Behavior—A Study of the Potential of VR

Can improving climate change perception lead to more environmentally friendly choices? Evidence from an immersive virtual environment experiment

Exploring the Use of Virtual Reality to Support Environmentally Sustainable Behavior: A Framework to Design Experiences

Making choices of food and non‐food products: a comparison between virtual stores and online shopping