Abstract:It is challenging to accurately differentiate and simulate different runoff components yielded under the saturation-excess and infiltration-excess mechanisms in semi-arid and semi-humid watersheds. Fixed model structures and runoff generation modes in most of the existing conventional hydrological models limit their ability to account for respective contributions of saturation-excess and infiltration-excess flows to flood processes. To conquer this limitation, this study developed a new flexible hybrid runoff generation modeling framework, which is named as spatial combination computing models (SCCMs) for runoff generation. SCCMs can determine the dominant runoff generation mode, either saturation-excess or infiltration-excess, on the sub-watershed level and then adopt one of the Xinanjiang (XAJ), Xinanjiang-Green Ampt (XAJG) and Green-Ampt (GA) runoff generation schemes to compute runoff generation at each sub-watershed. The logical combination of the above three runoff generation schemes led to six flavors of SCCMs. Curve number and topographic index are used for dividing a watershed into infiltration-excess dominated and saturation-excess dominated sub-watersheds. The proposed models were tested in two typical semi-humid (Dongwan) and semi-arid (Zhidan) watersheds. The multi-objective generalized likelihood uncertainty estimation method (GLUE) was used to analyze the parameter uncertainty of SCCMs. The results show that all two-scheme SCCMs outperform any of the single-scheme SCCMs. SCCM-2c (a combination model of XAJ and XAJG) achieves the best performance in the semi-humid Dongwan Watershed, while SCCM-5c (a combination model of XAJG and GA) performs best in the semi-arid Zhidan Watershed. The multi-objective GLUE-based uncertainty analysis shows that parameter uncertainties of the two-scheme SCCMs (SCCM-2c and SCCM-5c) are slightly lower than those of the single-scheme SCCMs (SCCM-1n, i.e., the XAJ model, and SCCM-6n, i.e., the GA model), indicating that increased model complexity in SCCMs does not cause increased model parameter uncertainty. Our results indicate that SCCMs with more realistic representation of spatial heterogeneity can achieve higher simulation accuracies and even lower uncertainties than the conventional single-scheme models.

A variable storage coefficient model for rainfall—runoff computation / Modèle pluie—débit basé sur un coefficient de stockage variable

A Generalized Storage Function Model for the Water Level Estimation Using Rating Curve Relationship

A genetic algorithm's novel rainfall distribution method for optimized hydrological modeling at basin scales

Verification of a New Spatial Distribution Function of Soil Water Storage Capacity Using Conceptual and SWAT Models

Seamless Integration of Rainfall Spatial Variability and a Conceptual Hydrological Model

Integrating hybrid runoff generation mechanism into variable infiltration capacity model to facilitate hydrological simulations

Spatial variability of rainfall: deciphering flood characteristics and model precision

A Model Combination Approach for Improving Streamflow Prediction

Hydrological Response to Agricultural Land Use Heterogeneity Using Variable Infiltration Capacity Model

Possibility of using the STORAGE rainfall generator model in the flood analyses in urban areas

Identification of Possible Incoming Runoff using Different Combinations of Extreme Rainfall Events in a Semi-arid Context: Banas River, Bisalpur Dam Catchment

Response of Runoff to Meteorological Factors Based on Time-Varying Parameter Vector Autoregressive Model with Stochastic Volatility in Arid and Semi-Arid Area of Weihe River Basin

Regional scale rainfall–runoff modeling using VARX–MGARCH approach

Enhancing runoff simulation precision in the critical zone through spatiotemporal interpolation of areal rainfall with matrix decomposition

A hybrid runoff generation modelling framework based on spatial combination of three runoff generation schemes for semi-humid and semi-arid watersheds

Parameter Allocation Approach for Runoff Simulation in an Arid Catchment using the KINEROS2 Hydrological Model

Hillslope scale conceptualization of hydrological processes for data-limited catchments and hypothesis testing by systematic model comparison

A Bayesian Surveillance Model to Track Variable Rainfall-Runoff Responses for Small Watersheds

Comparative analysis of HEC-HMS and SWAT hydrological models for simulating the streamflow in sub-humid tropical region in India

The General Formulation for Runoff Components Estimation and Attribution at Mean Annual Time Scale

Identifying best combination of methodologies for event-based hydrological modeling using HEC-HMS software: a case study on the Panchganga River basin, India