Abstract:Purpose The purpose of this paper is to investigate the market microstructure related to the Farm Credit System (FCS), Commercial Banks (CB) and Farm Services Administration (FSA). The commercial banks frequently call out the FCS as having an unfair advantage in the agricultural finance market place due to tax exempt bonds, and an implied guarantee of those bonds. This paper addresses the issue by examining the interrelationships since 1939, while addressing the historically distinctive roles that the FCS, CB and FSA have played in the US agricultural credit market. Design/methodology/approach There are two components to our model. The first is the estimation of short and long run credit demand elasticities, as well as land elasticities. These are estimated from a dynamic duality model using seemingly unrelated regression. The point elasticity measures are then used as independent variables in least square regressions, combined with farm specific and related macro variables, for the Cornbelt states. The dependent variable is the year-over-year changes in paired FCS, CB and FSA loans. Findings The genesis of the FCS was to provide credit to farmers in good and bad years. Therefore, we expected to see a countercyclical relationship between FCS and CB. This is found for the farm crisis years in the 1980s but is not a continuous characteristic of FCS lending. In good times the FCS and CB appear to compete, albeit with differentiated market segmentation into short- and long-term credit. The FSA, which was established to provide tertiary support to both the FCS and CB, appears to be responding as designed, with greater activity in bad years. The authors find the elasticity measures to be economically significant. Research limitations/implications The authors conclude that the market microstructure of the agricultural credit market in the US is important. Our analysis applies a broader definition of market microstructure for institutions and intermediaries and reveals that further research examining the economic frictions caused by comparative bond vs deposit funding of agricultural credit is important. Originality/value The authors believe that this is the first paper to examine agricultural finance through the market microstructure lens. In addition our long-term data measures allow us to examine the economics through various sub-periods. Finally, we believe that our introduction of credit and land demand elasticities into a comparative credit model is also a first.

Analysis of Credit Access, U.S. Agricultural Productivity, and Residual Returns to Resources

American Farm Credit System (FCS) and Its Enlightenment

Effects of agricultural credit facility on the agricultural production and rural development

The Effects of Access to Credit on Productivity Among Microenterprises: Separating Technological Changes from Changes in Technical Efficiency

Federal crop insurance and agricultural credit use

Credit constraints and productivity in Peruvian agriculture

Credit Constraint and return to farmer investment——Evidence From a Survey in Yunnan and Ningxia Provinces

The Impact of Farmers' Borrowing Behavior on Agricultural Production Technical Efficiency

The Impact of Rural Credit on Cultivated Land Use Efficiency: An Empirical Analysis Using China Rural Revitalization Survey Data

Market microstructure and the historical relationship between the US farm credit system, farm service agency and commercial bank lending

Impact of Credit and Investment Resources on the Productivity of Agricultural Sector

The role of credit resources in financial support of agricultural manufacturers in modern economic conditions

Factors Determining Farmers’ Access to and Sources of Credit: Evidence from the Rain-Fed Zone of Pakistan

Measuring public agricultural research and extension and estimating their impacts on agricultural productivity: new insights from U.S. evidence

Does Agricultural Credit Input Promote Agricultural Green Total Factor Productivity? Evidence from Spatial Panel Data of 30 Provinces in China

The Nexus between Agricultural Productivity, Oil Prices, Economic Growth, and Financial Development in the USA

Rural Credit and Farms Efficiency: Modelling Farmers Credit Allocation Decisions, Evidences from Benin

Impact of Agricultural Credit on Agricultural Production: Evidence from Bangladesh

Risk Rationing and Wealth Effects in Credit Markets: Theory and Implications for Agricultural Development

Raising Maize Productivity Through Agricultural Credit A: Case Study of Commercial Banks in Pakistan

Impact of Broadband Penetration on U.S. Farm Productivity