Abstract:Introduction Evidence‐based practice supports clinical decision‐making by using multiple sources of evidence arising from research and practice. Research evidence develops through empirical study while practice evidence arises through clinical experience, client preferences, and the practice context. Although occupational therapists have embraced the paradigm of evidence‐based practice, some studies have identified limits in the availability and use of research, which can lead to reliance on other forms of evidence. This study aimed to understand how Australian occupational therapists use practice evidence, manage potential bias, and enhance trustworthiness. Potential use of a critical appraisal tool for practice evidence was also explored. Methods A 42‐item questionnaire was developed to address the study aims. It consisted of a 7‐point Likert scale, ordinal and free text questions. Likert scales were collapsed into binary scales and analysed using SPSS. Ordinal data were graphed and free text responses were analysed using manifest content analysis. Results Most respondents (82%) indicated that practice evidence was an important informant of practice and is used alongside research evidence. Almost all respondents (98%) expressed confusion when reconciling discrepancies between research and practice evidence. There was general acknowledgement that practice evidence is prone to bias (82%), yet 92% were confident in trusting their own practice evidence. Most respondents (74.5%) undertook some measures to appraise practice evidence, and almost all respondents (90%) agreed they would refer to a critical appraisal tool that helped them evaluate practice evidence. Conclusion Occupational therapists in this study routinely use practice evidence arising from their own experience, client perspectives, and their practice context to inform clinical decision‐making. While they agreed that practice evidence was prone to bias and misinterpretation, they generally trusted their own practice evidence. Participants indicated they needed guidance to critically appraise their practice evidence and supported the development of a critical appraisal tool for this purpose.

Celebrating the Insecure Practitioner. A Critique of Evidence-Based Practice in Adapted Physical Activity

Philosophy, Adapted Physical Activity and Dis/ability

Questioning evidence-based practice in physiotherapy: a philosophical reflection. The example of physiotherapy with musicians

'A challenge to my professional identity'- resisting the shift from over-management to self-management for back pain within an implementation trial: a qualitative study

The use of practice evidence by Australian occupational therapists: Perspectives and actions

Exercising Caution: A Case for Ethics Analysis in Physical Activity Promotion

Hard bodies: exploring historical and cultural factors in disabled people’s participation in exercise; applying critical disability theory

Challenging ableism and the ‘disability as problem’ discourse: how initial teacher education can support the inclusion of students with a disability in physical education

Perspectives on how evidence‐based practice changes over time: A qualitative exploration of occupational therapy and physical therapy graduates

The post 16 gap: how do young people conceptualise PE? An exploration of the barriers to participation in physical education, physical activity and sport in senior school pupils

Perceptions and beliefs of community-based fitness professionals working with people with disability: a qualitative study

Physiotherapists' perceptions of implementing evidence-based practice for patients with low back pain through the Enhanced Transtheoretical Model Intervention: a qualitative study

"We cannot CBT our way out of these systems": Exploring how sport psychology practitioners engage in cultural praxis

Evidence-based yet still challenging! Research on physical activity in old age

Ableism as a regulator of social practice and disabled peoples’ self-determination to participate in sport and physical activity

Private practice model of physiotherapy: professional challenges identified through an exploratory qualitative study

Health sciences training for disability inclusion: the need to engage with emotion

Fidelity, pragmatism and the "grey line" in between-exploring the delivery of a pragmatic physical activity randomised controlled trial-a secondary analysis

Implementing evidence-based physical activity interventions for people with mental illness: an Australian perspective

Attempting to Close the Evidence-Practice Gap in Physical Activity Intervention Research: Strategies and Outcomes of a Co-Creative Qualitative Study

'It's a challenge': Post primary physical education teachers' experiences of and perspectives on inclusive practice with students with disabilities