Abstract:Mismatches between cues can occur when they persist in the environment for different periods of time, potentially increasing uncertainty about which mate to choose. We found that patches with a mismatch between cues signalling female mating status led to intermediate survival costs in males, with the substrate cues left by females being instrumental for males to find their mates quicker but at the expense of mating with females and not fertilising their offspring. Multiple cues are often used for mate choice in complex environments, potentially entailing mismatches in the information conveyed by different sources. We address the consequences of this information mismatch for receivers using the spider mite Tetranychus urticae, in which virgin females are highly valuable mates compared to mated females, given first male sperm precedence. Accordingly, males are known to prefer virgins and distinguish them using cues from the females themselves and that they leave on the substrate. Whereas cues from females are highly reliable, those left on the substrate may not reflect the real female mating status if females move and/or mate. Here, we tested the consequences of such mismatch by exposing males to mated or virgin females on patches previously impregnated with cues deposited by females of either mating status. Male mating attempts were solely affected by substrate cues while female acceptance and the number of mating events were independently affected by both cues. Copulation duration, in contrast, depended mainly on the mating status of the female, with the number of copulations and the total time spent mating being intermediate in environments with mismatched information. We also show that males incur mating costs, reflected in reduced survival in environments with virgin cues. These results suggest that substrate cues left by females are instrumental for males to find their mates. However, in environments with mismatched information, males may pay survival costs without the associated benefit of mating with virgins, or they may lose opportunities to mate with virgins by responding to substrate cues from mated females. The benefit of using multiple cues will then hinge upon the frequency of information mismatch, which itself should vary with the dynamics of populations.

Male Fish Deceive Competitors about Mating Preferences

Aesthetic preference for artificially selected color variant affects mate choice copying behavior in female Poecilia latipinna

When Rivals Are Absent: Male Aggression Towards Females in Bluefin Killifish

Sensory trap leads to reliable communication without a shift in nonsexual responses to the model cue

Context-dependent evaluation of prospective mates in a fish

Male-male interactions shape mate selection in Drosophila

Female comparative mate choice influences strategic male nesting strategy in the peacock blenny Salaria pavo

Arms races, ornaments and fragrant genes: the dilemma of mate choice in fishes

Female mate choice and the emergence of male coercion

Deceptive copulation calls attract female visitors to peacock leks

Lie to me to lay with me: Females deceive males via terminal investment

A Theoretical Comparison of Alternative Male Mating Strategies in Cephalopods and Fishes

Fake news? The impact of information mismatch on mating behaviour

A tale of two males: Behavioral and neural mechanisms of alternative reproductive tactics in midshipman fish

No evidence for mate copying in Danio rerio

Sexual Selection: Mating Behavior Tendencies in Guppies in Response to Various Artificial 3D Models

Perceived mate competition risk influences the female mate choice and increases the reproductive effort in the annual killifish Millerichthys robustus

No geographical differences in male mate choice in a widespread fish, Limia perugiae

Females can solve the problem of low signal reliability by assessing multiple male traits

The decision of male medaka to mate or fight depends on two complementary androgen signaling pathways

Male reproductive phenotype and coercive mating performance in the guppy