A Tax Integrated Approach for Global Supply Chain Network Planning

Kannan Balaji,Nukala Viswanadham,K. Balaji,N. Viswanadham
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/tase.2008.923823
IF: 6.636
2008-10-01
IEEE Transactions on Automation Science and Engineering
Abstract:Globalization is here to stay. Companies source, manufacture, and sell across borders. There are several destinations available for undertaking these activities offering varying degrees of incentives and at each destination the company incurs a different delivery cost. Multinational companies need to make more realistic decisions about where to make, source, locate, move, and store products to minimize the total cost of delivery keeping in mind the incentives offered by the governments and the logistics costs at and from the location. Current literature on supply chain optimization does not emphasize on tax. To attract foreign investment, many developing economies have included tax-holidays in their export-import (EXIM) policy for companies operating in free trade zones (FTZs). In this paper, we propose a tax integrated mixed integer model, for optimally deciding the foreign direct investment (FDI)-outsourcing (the choice of establishing captive production centers versus complete outsourcing) alternatives at the various stages of a global supply chain. For a general acyclic supply chain, this decision problem is NP-hard and obtaining analytical results on optimal FDI-outsourcing strategy may be difficult. We linearize the tax integrated model by introducing exactly one hub at each stage. In this case, termed hub-based sourcing—single hub case, we prove that the greedy strategy is an optimal FDI-outsourcing strategy. However, by associating multiple hubs at each stage the decision problem remains NP-hard. Finally, we empirically analyze the tax integrated model (for the general case) on a use-case scenario in which some locations in the choice have free trade zones offering tax incentives. Note to Practitioners—Global outsourcing is a common practice now in manufacturing and service industries. India and China with their skilled and low-cost human resources are potential destinations for outsourcing. Multinational firms making efforts to exploit these opportunities, have several alternatives before them. They can start a fully owned subsidiary or buy components or subassemblies from suppliers in low-cost countries or have joint ventures. Leading firms need to evaluate between the possible alternatives keeping in mind the logistics and other delivery costs as well as the taxes and tariffs. In this paper, we develop an optimization model to choose between the two extreme alternatives at each stage in the supply chain: FDI which implies establishing a fully owned subsidiary or outsourcing. Integrating tax policy while deciding between FDI versus outsourcing at the various stages of a supply chain would lead to the design of a cost competitive supply chain. In view of the importance of this strategic problem, economists and business analysts have started looking at it in an analytical way. Our paper is of immense practical utility for companies to make optimal entry decisions at each stage in its supply chain that minimizes the total cost which includes taxes and tariffs and meets the demand for its products or services in different countries (or regions). Tax integrated supply chain planning could save millions of dollars for companies operating globally.
automation & control systems
What problem does this paper attempt to address?