Abstract:Recent studies on the business impacts of information technology (IT) have examined these impacts in the context of either other organizational resources or contingency factors. In this study we integrate these perspectives to develop a contingent interaction model. This model examines how a firm’s IT investment interacts differently with resources focusing on creating value (i.e., R&D) and resources focusing on value appropriation (i.e., advertising), depending on the environmental turbulence in the firm’s industry. The results indicate that a firm’s IT interacts differently with other organizational resources depending on (a) the resource’s focus on value creation through innovation or value appropriation in the market; and (b) the extent of turbulence in the firm’s industry. Thus, managers should consider IT’s interactions with other resources while making IT investments. In turbulent and stable environments, managers should seek ways to use IT to complement R&D investments and advertising investments, respectively. Managers should also recognize that IT may erode some of the benefits of R&D and advertising investments in stable and turbulent environments, respectively. They should therefore exercise caution when making concurrent investments in IT and R&D in stable environments and exercise similar caution when making concurrent investments in IT and advertising in turbulent environments.Recent studies on the business value of information technology (BVIT) investments have focused on understanding IT’s impact on firm performance, either in the context of other organizational resources or in the light of contingency factors. This study extends the prior literature by integrating these two perspectives and examining the BVIT while simultaneously considering other organizational resources and one important contingency factor—environmental turbulence. We develop a contingent interaction model, proposing that a firm’s IT interacts differently with a resource focused on fostering innovation (i.e., research and development [R&D]) and a resource focused on enhancing the competitive gains in the market (i.e., advertising), depending on the extent of environmental turbulence in its industry. Specifically, we hypothesize that as the extent of environmental turbulence in a firm’s industry increases, the positive effect of the interaction between IT and R&D investments on firm performance increases, but the positive effect of the interaction between IT and advertising investments on firm performance decreases. Our findings, based on a longitudinal sample of 294 firms observed from 1999 to 2008 and collected from three archival sources (InformationWeek, COMPUSTAT, and CRSP) provide evidence that supports the proposed hypotheses. Additionally, the results of a split-sample analysis reveal that the interaction between IT and R&D has a positive effect on firm performance in turbulent environments but a negative effect in stable environments. Conversely, the interaction between IT and advertising has a negative effect on firm performance in turbulent environments but a positive effect in stable environments. Put together, these findings indicate that a firm’s IT interacts differently with other organizational resources depending on (a) the resource’s focus on value creation through innovation or value appropriation in the market; and (b) the extent of turbulence in the firm’s industry. This paper discusses the theoretical and empirical implications of these findings in detail. The online appendix is available at https://doi.org/10.1287/isre.2018.0803 .

Information Technology Implementation Research: A Technological Diffusion Approach

Examining the role of innovation diffusion factors on the implementation success of enterprise resource planning systems

An Investigation of Resource-Based and Institutional Theoretic Factors in Technology Adoption for Operations and Supply Chain Management

An Empirical Test of the Information Processing Theory

The Influence of Profitability and Bandwagon Pressure on New Technology Diffusion: A Empirical Study on EC Technology

Impact of Information Technology Integration and Lean/Just-In-Time Practices on Lead-Time Performance

The Distinct Effects of Information Technology and Communication Technology on Firm Organization

The implementation and adoption of new technology in organizations: The impact on work, people, and culture

An Examination of “Push-Pull” Theory Applied to Process Innovation in Knowledge Work

A field study of the adoption of software process innovations by information systems professionals

The Impact of Intelligent Manufacturing on Labor Productivity: an Empirical Analysis of Chinese Listed Manufacturing Companies

A Field Study of RFID Deployment and Return Expectations

Understanding Dynamic Competitive Technology Diffusion in Electronic Markets.

Relationships Between Information Technology and Other Investments: A Contingent Interaction Model

Internal Infrastructural Impacts on RFID Perceptions and Commitment: Knowledge, Operational Procedures, and Information-Processing Standards

Manufacturing in the Digital Age: Exploiting Information Technologies for Product Realization

Why do people use information technology? A critical review of the technology acceptance model

Innovation adoption and diffusion in business-to-business marketing

Influence of Information and Communication Technology Infrastructure on the Adoption of Enterprise Resource Planning at The Kenya Medical Research Institute in Nairobi City County, Kenya

Self-reliance or dependence? patterns of information technology use on innovation performance

Path dependent constraints on innovation programmes in production and operations management