The past is a foreign country: amnesia and marketing theory

Mark Tadajewski,Michael Saren

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/1470593108096539

2008-12-01

Marketing Theory

Abstract:This paper introduces the special issue. Using the work of Connerton (2008) as our prism, we examine the role of amnesia in marketing theory, stressing its positive and negative benefits. Key Words • amnesia • critical marketing studies• structuring of marketing theory

business

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Marketing, the past and corporate heritage

John M. T. Balmer,Mario Burghausen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/1470593118790636

2018-08-02

Marketing Theory

Abstract:We argue for a more expansive conceptualization of the past’s relevance in, and for, marketing. Such a differentiated approach to the past is pregnant with possibilities in terms of advancing scholarship apropos temporal agency in marketing along with consumption practices. Symptomatic of this perspective is the increased mindfulness of the rich palate of past-related concepts. Significantly, the corporate heritage notion – because of its omnitemporal nature – represents a distinct and meaningful vector on the past by coalescing the past, present and future into a new type of temporality. As such, the authors reason this expansive conceptualization of ‘the past-in-marketing’ is both timely and efficacious. While sensitive of the importance of the historical method in marketing and the history of marketing scholarship and practice per se, this broader marketing approach to and of the past highlights the ideational and material manifestations of the past-in-the-present and an envisaged past-in-the-future.

business
This Won't Last Forever: Benefits and Costs of Anticipatory Nostalgia.

Xinyue Zhou,Rong Huang,Krystine Batcho,Weiling Ye

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2020.577308

IF: 3.8

2020-01-01

Frontiers in Psychology

Abstract:What helps consumers extract the greatest happiness from their experiences? The current investigation is the first to introduce to the consumer literature the construct of anticipatory nostalgia, defined as missing aspects of the present before they vanish in the future. While personal nostalgia involves fond memories and longing for what has already been lost, anticipatory nostalgia involves missing what has not yet been lost. In four studies, we show that marketing communications can elicit anticipatory nostalgia, and this emotion can either enhance or reduce consumer enjoyment of the experience, depending on the experience valence or the individual's level of life satisfaction. Specifically, mediated by anxiety, anticipatory nostalgia decreased enjoyment and positive affect in pleasant situations, but it enhanced enjoyment and affect in unpleasant circumstances. Study 4 extended the paradigm to a real-life setting and showed that the impact of anticipatory nostalgia on enjoyment and meaningfulness can last as long as 8 h after the manipulation.
The haunting specter of retro consumption

Oscar Ahlberg,Joel Hietanen,Tuomas Soila

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/1470593120966700

2020-10-23

Marketing Theory

Abstract:We propose to intensify theorizing on retromarketing and nostalgic consumption by further developing “hauntology” as a conceptual lens for assessing the retro aesthetic as a commodified affective excess of meaning. This allows us to explore the consumption of marketized retrospective signs not from the perspective of personal experiences or creative meaning-makings but rather as affective encounters that desire in consumption desperately latches onto. In our view, it is thus not an aesthetic satisfaction, nostalgic comfort, or playful emancipations that are offered to us by retro consumption. Following a darker development of hauntology, we find ourselves instead thrust into spectral presences that we can never quite articulate, a haunting within us in an atmosphere of late capitalism where temporal belief in the future has been “cancelled.”

business
Who Needs Memory? the Case for the Markovian Organisation

Jonathan Klein,Con Connell,Sajjad Jasimuddin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1057/palgrave.kmrp.8500130

2007-01-01

Knowledge Management Research & Practice

Abstract:This paper examines the contradiction of organisational memory: that an organisation requires a memory to operate effectively, but that that same memory inhibits and constrains its ability to operate effectively. We briefly review the field of organisational memory and note its close connection with organisational learning.We introduce a conceptual framework pioneered by Schultze and Stabell for examining contradictions in the area of knowledge management. We use this framework to distinguish between the conventional view of organisational memory, which implicitly or explicitly regards knowledge as a commodity, and a constructivist view, from which emerges a picture of the Markovian organisation: an organisation the future behaviour of which is determined not by memories of the past but by its current state, characterised by an organisational consciousness informed by the activities in which it is engaged. While the emphasis of this paper is theoretical, we suggest that adopting this Markovian view of the organisation might be particularly appropriate to practitioners in organisations that are immersed in turbulent environments.
Experience Marketing: Concepts, Frameworks and Consumer Insights

Bernd Schmitt

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1561/1700000027

2010-01-01

Foundations and Trends® in Marketing

Abstract:<div>Experience is a new and exciting concept marketing academia and practice. This monograph reviews the various meanings of experience as the term is used in philosophy, psychology, and in consumer behavior and marketing. I will discuss the key concepts of experience marketing such as experiential value, different types of experiences, the distinction between ordinary and extraordinary experiences and experience touchpoints. I will also review the empirical findings that provide consumer insights on experiences — such as how experiences are remembered, whether positive and negative experiences can co-exist, how experiential attributes are processed and whether experiences are rational. Practical frameworks for managing and marketing experiences will be discussed. I will conclude with an exploration of how experience marketing can contribute to customer happiness.<h3>Suggested Citation</h3>Bernd Schmitt (2011), "Experience Marketing: Concepts, Frameworks and Consumer Insights", Foundations and Trends® in Marketing: Vol. 5: No. 2, pp 55-112. http://dx.doi.org/10.1561/1700000027</div>
Memory, Imagination, and Knowledge

Dan Manolescu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.46809/jcsll.v4i6.231

2023-10-25

Journal of Critical Studies in language and literature

Abstract:The present article invites the reader to re-appraise the values of memory, imagination, and knowledge from a new perspective and with an abundance of various opinions, ideas, and commentaries. At the beginning of the 21st century, the growth by leaps and bounds of technology has made this re-evaluation even more relevant now that we have access to all kinds of sources of information. Such a fresh perspective becomes feasible and necessary, given the tools and possibilities offered, literally, by a wealth of sources at our fingertips. Using references available in historical documents as well as contemporary electronic and mass media communication, the discussion centers on a thorough analysis of memory and imagination with their obvious effects on the retention of knowledge. The positive outcome of such an approach is also relevant when we take a good look at the quest for knowledge and its intrinsic value. Research of material produced over centuries and millennia leads us to pursue the study of memory and imagination and, through them, perceive the acquisition of knowledge as beneficial and much-needed in the entire process of education.
Decision-making in international marketing: past, present and future

João S. Oliveira,Magnus Hultman,Nathaniel Boso,Ian Hodgkinson,Paul Hughes,Ekaterina Nemkova,Anne Souchon

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1108/imr-11-2022-0249

2023-08-22

International Marketing Review

Abstract:Purpose This special issue seeks to create an interdisciplinary community of researchers applying decision-making theory to the international marketing context. The articles published in this special issue contain cutting-edge conceptual and empirical studies that enhance existing knowledge on international marketing decision-making. Design/methodology/approach Thirty-six (36) manuscripts were submitted to the editorial office focusing on a broad range of international marketing decision-making. Following a thorough review process, a collection of five original empirical studies on different facets of international marketing decision-making from multiple theoretical, contextual and methodological perspectives are included in this Special Issue. Findings Overall, the combined evidence presented in this Special Issue shows that the general field of international marketing decision-making is starting to mature. Evidence from the contributors to this Special Issue shows that researchers have taken inspiration from both the past and the present when designing and crafting their research and, by doing so, they have collectively contributed to new knowledge in terms of international marketing decision-making principles, decision-maker personality traits, the consequences of international marketing decisions and cross-cultural differences with regards to decision-making influences and behavior. Originality/value With few exceptions, not much is known about how international marketing decisions are made. Yet, the way international marketing decisions are made is critical for international marketing success. This sphere of international marketing decision-making research, while relatively anemic, is typically underpinned by behavioral economic theories of decision-making, such that a duality in decision-making processes is identified. Nevertheless, international marketing and management studies are dominated by the planning paradigm, while in practice, managers often see the attempt to deviate from planning as irresponsible and dangerous. The articles included in this special issue have addressed major unanswered questions regarding the content and processes of international marketing decision-making.

business
Writing telepathy back into marketing theory

Mark Tadajewski

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/14705931221095611

2022-05-22

Marketing Theory

Abstract:Marketing Theory, Ahead of Print. Adopting a commitment to the principle of heterogeneity, combined with a concern for subjugated and disqualified knowledge, we unravel the debates around telepathy and telementation in marketing theory and practice. We explicate the conditions of possibility for these deliberations, focusing on the Society for Psychical Research (SPR). A close reading of the scholarly outputs published by members of the SPR helps us unpack the theoretical assumptions underwriting telepathy via the concept of the subliminal self. This material forms the foundations for William Walker Atkinson's 'practical occultism'. We review Atkinson's work, making the case that telepathy was central to exerting personal influence. Our account thus diverges markedly from extant histories of influence. Attention is then turned to the jettisoning of telepathic linkages. Changes in discourse reflect 'epistemological deflation' in combination with 'counter-reversal'. Nonetheless, telepathic and telementative assumptions remain central to our understanding of sales and marketing communications. The same can be said of consumer research. Telepathy may also impact our future in a novel, 'synthetic' form.

business
Historizing the present: Research agenda and implications for consumer behavior

Dafna Goor,Anat Keinan,Nailya Ordabayeva

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/jcpy.1417

IF: 4.551

2024-03-13

Journal of Consumer Psychology

Abstract:This paper conceptualizes the phenomenon of historizing the present, defined as emphasizing the historical significance of present events and treating the present from the perspective of history. The authors identify four modes of historizing the present (emphasizing that: (1) the present will shape history; (2) the present is a unique moment in history; (3) the present will be remembered in history; (4) the present echoes history) and demonstrate how historizing can be employed by marketers of for‐profit and nonprofit organizations in a variety of contexts. The paper examines the psychological implications of appreciating the historical significance of the present and outlines a research agenda for studying the downstream behavioral consequences of historizing the present across diverse substantive consumer domains. It concludes with an examination of the broader societal implications of historizing the present as well as its implications for consumer well‐being.

psychology, applied,business
Forgetting the wars: Australian war memorials and amnesia

J. Stephens

Abstract:This chapter examines the role of forgetfulness in Australian war memorials. It traces the notion of memory and its relationship with national identity and Anzac as a background to understand what part these play in Australian memorialisation. Forgetfulness is a crucial part of the memory process and its role in inducing social or collective amnesia a necessary (if sometimes unsafe) part of war remembrance. Collective amnesia is the product of processes, both official and individual, that mask aspects of war represented in war memorial design and in the rituals that accompany war commemoration in memorial spaces. Memorials are complex sites and I argue that forgetting and amnesia in memorial designs and use is possibly an essential condition of their being. They are contradictory places where the contest of remembering and forgetting is played out. The Stolpersteine remembr~ce program in Europe illustrates this contest.

History,Sociology
Nostalgia Tendency and the Purchase Intention of Cultural and Creative Products

Jianwan Jing,

DOI: https://doi.org/10.47510/jeat.2022.4.1.19

2022-06-30

The East Asian Trade Association

Abstract:Purpose – The global economy is changing from material to mental and cultural consumption. Nostalgic consumption is emerging as a new consumption model for the cultural content industry. Under this background, the text studies the relationship between the consumer’s nostalgia tendency and the willingness to purchase creative products using the nostalgic consumption behavior mechanism. Design/Methodology/Approach – This study examines the effect on the intention to purchase creative products from the perspective of consumers’ nostalgia. Findings – This study provides complementary theoretical significance to the study of the nostalgic consumption behavior of cultural and creative products. At the same time, it provides practical reference significance for the future marketing strategy and development of cultural and creative industry. Research Implications – Nostalgia is a unique characteristic that consumers generally have and, at the same time, a kind of psychology that can affect the purchase of a brand phenomenon. Consumer’s emotional response that evokes nostalgia and psychology related to stimulants are attitudes toward products that evoke consumer nostalgia. Sierra and McQuitty (2007) text expressed that consumers’ tendency to evoke nostalgia is advantageous in improving their willingness to purchase creative products based on the consumption behavior mechanism that evokes nostalgia. Therefore, nostalgia should be added to products or brands in the future development of the cultural and creative industries. Products can be enriched with nostalgic elements such as the country’s cultural history, memories of homes and childhood, symbolic meaning and preferences, characteristics of the times and cultural properties.
Reflections on the history of marketing thought and theory development

Robert D. Tamilia

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/1470593111418808

2011-12-01

Marketing Theory

Abstract:What happens when accumulated knowledge from the past as regards both practice and theory is absent in marketing education? Simply put, scholarly knowledge gets lost with dire consequences not only for the nature and scope of marketing as an academic discipline but also for the type of research undertaken. The quest to be current, especially in marketing management, has resulted in the fragmentation of marketing into ever more specialized areas resulting in the creation of silos with little room for scholarly work in marketing thought and marketing theory building.

business
Brand heritage as a temporal perception: conceptualisation, measure and consequences

Fabien Pecot,Pierre Valette-Florence,Virginie De Barnier

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/0267257X.2019.1667414

IF: 4.707

2019-11-25

Journal of Marketing Management

Abstract:This research looks at the concept of brand heritage as a branded representation of the past and its influence on cognitive and affective responses. Although numerous items of research mention brand heritage, the subject still lacks conceptual clarity. This paper aims to address this gap and to build a scale measuring its perception by consumers. The literature review leads to a conceptualisation of brand heritage as the perception of a brand's temporal management. Then, one qualitative and three quantitative studies facilitate the emergence and validate a three-dimensional scale of perceived brand heritage. A model demonstrates how brand heritage enhances brand credibility and personal nostalgia. This paper contributes to the apprehension of change and continuity in brand management, with potential extensions to other disciplines.

management,business
Nostalgia and Forestalgia: Insights, Evaluation, and Implications for Advertising and Product Typology

R. Wixel Barnwell,Joel Collier,Kevin J. Shanahan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00913367.2022.2036652

IF: 6.528

2022-04-05

Journal of Advertising

Abstract:While the focus for many advertising academics and practitioners has been on nostalgia, there is a dearth of research on future-focused appeals. We introduce a new concept, forestalgia, or a consumer's yearning for an idealized future. To understand the impact of nostalgia and forestalgia, qualitative background interviews were conducted with creative directors and other advertising creatives from numerous nationally recognized advertising agencies. Building on the insights from the interviews and using construal level theory as our foundation, we explore consumer response to hedonic and utilitarian products when appeals employ far-past, near-past, near-future, and far-future framing. Thus, we examine whether nostalgia or forestalgia is better suited for certain products. We find utilitarian products are better received with a temporal distance that is far from the present with hedonic products better suited for appeals framed in the far past and near future. Managerial and theoretical implications are discussed, along with future research considerations.

communication,business
Spectacular memory: Zombie pasts in the themed shopping malls of Dubai

Paul O’Connor

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/17506980211066579

IF: 1.053

2022-01-16

Memory Studies

Abstract:Memory invariably involves sifting and sorting historical traces and reassembling them into societal representations of the past. Usually this has been done by social groups of different kinds or the cultural institutions associated with them, and has provided materials for the construction and maintenance of group identity. In what I term “spectacular memory,” however, the sifting and sorting of memory traces is performed by commercial and media institutions within a globalized cultural framework to create spectacles for mass consumption. Spectacular memory is enabled by the progressive breakdown of Halbwach’s “social frameworks of memory”—the association of memory with face-to-face relations within social groups. In late modern societies, “memory” as a coherent body of representations which is the property of more-or-less bounded social groups has largely devolved into a globalized store of representations curated and diffused through the media, advertising, tourism and entertainment industries. This article uses the example of the history-themed shopping malls of Dubai to characterize this form of memory.

cultural studies,history
A history of theories of decision-making and technologies for observation in the service of marketing

Joshua M. Penrod

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1108/jhrm-07-2020-0030

2023-01-26

Journal of Historical Research in Marketing

Abstract:Purpose Brain and behavioral research is a hallmark of knowledge and understanding within modern society and has taken on greater importance in the commercial context; as this area unfolds, the intersection of the science, technology and marketing is an important and topical area for exploration. Design/methodology/approach This work tracks the parallel history of the technologies and science of the brain because it grows in relevance for the study of marketing and consumer behavior. It is an historical review of the usage of technologies to measure brain activity and behavior, parallel to the development of psychological theories created to account for human decision-making from the 1940s until the present. Findings This essay presents a new conception of "closure" and "momentum," as envisioned by social construction of technology and technological momentum theories, arriving at a new concept for inclusion called "convergence" which offers a multifactor explanation for the acceptance, technical implementation and its commercial application. Originality/value It is an original adaptation of theories from across several fields that yields insight into the integration of science, technology, society and business.
The battle over the past: The role of occupational groups in organizational memory

Eneli Kindsiko,Maaja Vadi,Anne Reino,Aet Kiisla

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/17506980241283892

IF: 1.053

2024-10-24

Memory Studies

Abstract:Memory Studies, Ahead of Print. This article delves into the intricate processes of memory within occupational groups, with a specific focus on perceiving memory as a way of adapting to a changing environment. We are investigating how individuals from two occupational groups in the university (academic and non-academic) navigate the process of remembering and forgetting to adapt to a changed environment (leadership change). Using two university colleges as case studies, we examine this phenomenon over a 1.5-year period via qualitative interviews. Our findings underscore that distinct occupational groups employ varied approaches to draw upon the past, where the key is in how they "sense" the situation. This article contributes by operationalizing four manifestations of "senses" to elucidate how organizational memory, encompassing both forgetting and remembering, operates as a means of adaptation.

cultural studies,history
Beyond difficult pasts: Towards a fuller understanding of memory-making in tourism

Alena Pfoser,Sabine Stach

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/17506980241300612

IF: 1.053

2024-12-01

Memory Studies

Abstract:Memory Studies, Ahead of Print. Despite being a crucial field for the public production and circulation of memories, tourism remains underexamined in memory research. This is reflected in the small number of publications dedicated to tourism and their thematic narrowing to difficult heritage sites. This article makes the case for an expansion of research in three areas: sites, modes and scales of remembering. First, the article argues for an examination of less researched heritage sites alongside considering non-site-based forms of memory production. Second, we contend that memory-making in tourism can contribute to a 'positive turn' in memory studies by foregrounding memories of joy and entertainment. Finally, we argue for a multiscalar perspective that draws attention to personal memories and memory's interscalar movements in tourism. Taken together, these shifts allow us to gain a fuller and more differentiated perspective on memory-making in tourism, informed by current debates in memory studies and insights from heritage and tourism studies.

cultural studies,history
A preliminary experimental test of the crossed influences between the valence of collective memory and collective future thinking

Octavia Ionescu,Jean Louis Tavani,Julie Collange

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/09658211.2024.2314983

2024-02-13

Memory

Abstract:This research experimentally examined the crossed influences between the emotional valence of collective memory and collective future thinking. As remembering the past and imagining the future are shaped by the present, we additionally test whether perceived anomie (i.e., perceiving present society as disintegrated and disregulated) would moderate these influences. Study 1 (N = 228 French participants) manipulated the valence of collective memory (positive vs. negative French past) to test its effect on the valence of collective future thinking. Results showed that the salience of a negative (vs. positive) French past lead to the projection of a more negative French future only among participants who perceived present society as highly disregulated. Study 2 (N = 215) focused on the influence of the valence of collective future thinking (positive vs. negative French future) on the valence associated with the French past. Results showed that the salience of a negative (vs. positive) French future lead left-wing participants to rate more positively events/figures of the French past that are usually valued by conservatives. Taken together, these studies provided evidence of conditional effects in the crossed influences between the emotional valence of collective memory and collective future thinking, thus contributing to the recent literature on collective mental time travel.

psychology, experimental

The past is a foreign country: amnesia and marketing theory

Marketing, the past and corporate heritage

This Won't Last Forever: Benefits and Costs of Anticipatory Nostalgia.

The haunting specter of retro consumption

Who Needs Memory? the Case for the Markovian Organisation

Experience Marketing: Concepts, Frameworks and Consumer Insights

Memory, Imagination, and Knowledge

Decision-making in international marketing: past, present and future

Writing telepathy back into marketing theory

Historizing the present: Research agenda and implications for consumer behavior

Forgetting the wars: Australian war memorials and amnesia

Nostalgia Tendency and the Purchase Intention of Cultural and Creative Products

Reflections on the history of marketing thought and theory development

Brand heritage as a temporal perception: conceptualisation, measure and consequences

Nostalgia and Forestalgia: Insights, Evaluation, and Implications for Advertising and Product Typology

Spectacular memory: Zombie pasts in the themed shopping malls of Dubai

A history of theories of decision-making and technologies for observation in the service of marketing

The battle over the past: The role of occupational groups in organizational memory

Beyond difficult pasts: Towards a fuller understanding of memory-making in tourism

A preliminary experimental test of the crossed influences between the valence of collective memory and collective future thinking