Abstract:The history and philosophy of music education are traced with varied efforts to hone, enhance, and shift a strong tradition of performance-based instruction. The purpose of this study is to summarize the research of Gumm's empirical models of eight music teaching and six conducting approaches and their application in the profession across three decades toward varied philosophical aims. Each approach coordinates a distinct set of instructional and motivational behaviors toward a particular learning effect or outcome. Different balances of approaches reveal broader aims, such as performance, comprehensive musicianship, cooperative, discovery, and affective learning, or even basic on-task behavior. Broader yet are two overarching aims found in common to both music teaching and conducting-to control or release. Controlling music teaching asserts correct on-task behavior through clear task directions and corrective feedback, motivates attention to task nonverbally, efficiently fills time with active tasks, and clarifies and affirms positive learning. In contrast, cooperative group leadership releases interdependent learning, questioning fosters music concept learning, imagery and movement release artistry, and discussing unique perspectives releases independent ideas and feelings. In conducting, precise gestures control accurate timing, signals and alerts motivate attention, and mimicry of musician exertions controls physical tone production; whereas shaping of phrases and score markings release musical expression, psychosocially familiarized gestures foster interdependence, and tension-easing gestures release freer independent tone production. Control-oriented teaching is most prevalent across the field, yet links to greater burnout and appeals to accommodating students motivated by effort and ability more than students motivated by social and affective enjoyment of music. In conducting, music-oriented precision and expression are more prevalent than musician-oriented approaches. Releasing approaches are more prevalent in Western than Eastern culture, upper levels, early rehearsals well before concerts, smaller ensembles, competitive ensembles, and teachers and conductors with greater experience or varied movement training. Conclusive implications are that the key to motivation is to draw attention to specific and intentional forms of learning, and that whatever is motivated to attention also motivates a particular philosophy of music education. Future research is suggested in general music and ethnic, folk, popular, community, and professional music ensembles.

Student Retention in School Bands and Orchestras: A Literature Review

Adopting an Organismic Perspective on Adolescent Academic Motivation for Instrumental Ensemble Participation

Who stays? Who goes? Motivation and tendency to drop out in music schools

The influence of socioeconomic status, parents, peers, psychological needs, and task values on middle school student motivation for school music ensemble participation

Participation and Persistence in High School Elective Music Ensembles

Choosing to study music in high school: Teacher support, psychological needs satisfaction, and elective music intentions

Psychological Needs and Motivational Outcomes in a High School Orchestra Program

Increasing Musical Persistence and Engagement in the Contemporary Music Classroom

Selected Nonmusic Predictors of Urban Students’ Decisions to Enroll and Persist in Middle and High School Music Ensemble Electives

Using Students’ Interests in General Music (Part 2): Exploratory Study of Upper Elementary Students’ Music Activity Interests

The key reasons for dropout in Slovenian music schools – a qualitative study

A Motivational Sequence Model of High School Ensemble Students’ Intentions to Continue Participating in Music

The support of autonomy, motivation, and music practice in university music students: A self-determination theory perspective

Music motivation depends on what to motivate: research review of Gumm's music teaching and conducting models

A Cross-Cultural Examination of University Students’ Motivation Toward Band and Academics in Singapore and the United States

Self-determination theory and motivation for music

Investigating Relationships Between Participation in High School Music Ensembles and Extra-musical Outcomes: An Analysis of the Education Longitudinal Study of 2002 using a Bioecological Development Model

Health Promotion and Prevention in Higher Music Education: Results of a Longitudinal Study

Student motivation to study music and sport - a comparison between study subjects and study programs on intrinsic and extrinsic motivational aspects

Classroom Management in K–12 Classroom Music: A Review of the Literature

Exploring support strategies for improving nursing student retention