Abstract:As app-based ride-hailing (or e-hailing) services have achieved great success worldwide, the traditional taxi industry faces an unprecedented crisis. To gain a deeper understanding of these two distinct modes that both offer door-to-door mobility services, in this study, we use Chicago as a case to comparatively analyze the travel patterns of the app-based ride-hailing and traditional taxi services and understand how socio-demographic and urban land use attributes affect the usage of two services in temporal and spatial dimensions. We employ the local regression models named geographically and temporally weighted regression (GTWR) models that can capture the spatiotemporal nonstationarity between variables as the primary analysis tool. Four GTWR models that predict the average hourly taxi or ride-hailing trip volume on weekdays or weekends for each community area are carefully constructed with R^2 all above 0.98. The nonstationarity test shows all variables exhibit extra local variations, indicating the necessity of using the GTWR models to explore the attributes' spatiotemporal impacts. Spatial error models (SEM) and ordinary least square (OLS) models, global regression models, are also built as comparisons and benchmark references. The differences between global and local regression models are illustrated through clustering analysis. To compare and contrast the usage patterns of ride-hailing and taxi services, we analyze the temporal-spatially varying coefficients of GTWR models. Interpretations are provided for our interesting findings, including the strong trip generation power of the population in the South Side area, the attitude of white people towards taxi services is positive but ambiguous towards ride-hailing services, young people's opposing behaviors towards taxi services on weekdays and weekends, and the opposite relationship between transit and taxi or ride-hailing in certain areas. Based on these key findings, we offer some planning and operational suggestions, such as developing mobile apps, implementing price-related strategies, strengthening partnerships with local businesses, building multi-modal transportation, clarifying customer segmentation, providing auxiliary services, etc.

Is ride-hailing a valuable means of transport in newly developed areas under TOD-oriented urbanization in China? Evidence from Chengdu City

How Does On-Demand Ridesplitting Influence Vehicle Use and Purchase Willingness? A Case Study in Hangzhou, China

A New Assessment Framework for TOD Design: Lessons Learned from Chinese Cities

Simulating On-Demand Ride Services in a Manhattan-like Urban Network Considering Traffic Dynamics

Exploring Competitiveness of Taxis to Ride-Hailing Services from a Multidimensional Spatio-Temporal Perspective: A Case Study in Beijing, China

Does travel closer to TOD have lower CO2 emissions? Evidence from ride-hailing in Chengdu, China

Travel Characteristics of Urban Residents Based on Taxi Trajectories in China: Beijing, Shanghai, Shenzhen, and Wuhan

Understanding the influencing factors of taxi ride-sharing: A case study of Chengdu, China

Comparative Analysis of Usage Patterns and Underlying Determinants for Ride-hailing and Traditional Taxi Services: A Chicago Case Study

Spatio-temporal Dynamics and Driving Mechanisms of Resident Trip in Small Cities

Exploring the spatially heterogeneous effect of the built environment on ride-hailing travel demand: A geographically weighted quantile regression model

Portraying ride-hailing mobility using multi-day trip order data: A case study of Beijing, China

Impact of Ride-Hailing Services on Transportation Mode Choices: Evidence from Traffic and Transit Ridership

Who loses and who wins in the ride-hailing era? A case study of Austin, Texas

An Empirical Study on Travel Patterns of Internet Based Ride-Sharing

Exploring the determinants of public transport usage and shared mobilities: A case study from Nanchang, China

Spatio-temporal analysis on online designated driving based on empirical data

Understanding the potential of taxi sharing: The case of Chengdu

Incorporating walking into ride-hailing: The potential benefits of flexible pick-up and drop-off

Taxi Passenger Travel Spatial and Temporal Characteristics Analysis and Application Based on Ridesourcing Data

Managing travelers' mode choices in the era of shared mobility through traditional traffic regulation policies