Abstract:Background Item memory and source memory are two important aspects of episodic memory. Recent studies about the behavioral characteristics and neural basis of item memory and source memory indicate that they are two different psychological processions. Two models have been proposed to describe the relation between these two kinds of memories: single-process model and dual-process model. Each model is supported by substantial evidence. Up to now, three kinds of paradigms have been formed to discriminate the relation between item memory and source memory:sequential task, three-button task and exclusion task. Reviews of these paradigms indicate that the results based on sequential task and three-button task are consistent whereas the results with exclusion task are not. Based on many event-related potential (ERP) studies, Cycowicz, et al. (2003) argued that the inconsistent results of exclusion task were due to the sensory-specific of source but not the test paradigm. To validate the results by Cycowicz, et al. and to extend previous study on item memory and source memory, the present ERP study was conducted to investigate the temporal and spatial distributions of the old/new effects for item recognition and location source retrieval on line drawing. Method Sixteen healthy undergraduates participated in this study. The stimuli were 400 drawings which were divided into 8 blocks. In each block, 30 drawings were presented either on left or on right screen during study phase, and then two tests were performed with 20 other drawings added. The first task was to decide whether each drawing presented at the central of the screen was learned or not, and the second task was to judge drawings learned from one location (left or right) as targets and other drawings as non-targets (called non-target-old or non-target-new) (exclusion task). Each drawing was displayed 500ms with the ISI of 1300ms and 1800ms during study phase and test phase respectively. EEG was recorded continuously using an Electro-cap with 62 locations (extended 10-20 system placements). Results The results were analyzed using a three-way repeated-measures ANOVA for three windows: 200~600ms, 600~1000ms,1000~1400ms. The three factors were memory judgment, left-right electrode sites and anterior-posterior sites. The ANOVA results indicated that the temporal distribution of the old/new effect for location source retrieval was longer than that of the old/new effect for item memory.Moreover, the spatial distribution of the former effect was wider than that of the latter. In other words, the old/new effect during 1000~1400ms for location source retrieval was not significant in item memory. The spatial and temporal distributive characteristics of the old/new effect for source memory were different from those of the previous studies. In addition, the old/new effects for target and non-target-old drawings were different. Conclusions First, location source retrieval is more difficult than item memory for drawing, which supports dual-process model. Second, Experimental paradigm and source characteristics regulate the spatial and temporal distributions of source retrieval effect together. Third, the level of consciousness during retrieval is also an important factor affecting source retrieval.

Source monitoring 15 years later: What have we learned from fMRI about the neural mechanisms of source memory?

Studies and Application of Memory Source Monitoring

Unraveling the brain mechanisms of source monitoring with non-invasive brain stimulation: A systematic review

Source Information is Inherently Linked to Working Memory Representation for Auditory but Not for Visual Stimuli

Could Source Amnesia Occur in the Context of Working Memory

Effects of Task Orientation on Subsequent Source Memory As Revealed by Functional MRI.

Reality monitoring and metacognitive judgments in a false-memory paradigm

Effects of Source Monitoring on the False Memory Caused by Mental Imagery

Two Faces of a Coin? A Systematic Review of Source Monitoring and Its Relationship with Memory in Autism

An integrative model of network activity during episodic memory retrieval and a meta-analysis of fMRI studies on source memory retrieval

An Event-Related Potentials Study of Item Memory and Location Source Retrieval of Line Drawing

Hippocampal subfields and their neocortical interactions during autobiographical memory

A Functional MRI Paradigm for Efficient Mapping of Memory Encoding Across Sensory Conditions

Reviews on the Studies of Reality Monitoring

Sensitivity of late ERP old/new effects in source memory to self-referential encoding focus and stimulus emotionality

Age differences in cue utilization during prospective and retrospective memory monitoring.

A Review of Studies on the Neural Mechanisms of Associative Memory

Visual Imagery and False Memory for Pictures: A Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging Study in Healthy Participants

Interactions of Emotion and Self-reference in Source Memory: An ERP Study

Multiple traces and altered signal-to-noise in systems consolidation: Evidence from the 7T fMRI Natural Scenes Dataset

Better memory for emotional sources? A systematic evaluation of source valence and arousal in source memory