Frontier Figures: American Music and the Mythology of the American West
Matthew S Mugmon
Abstract:Frontier Figures: American Music and the Mythology of the American West By Beth E. Levy. California Studies in 20th-Century Music 14. Berkeley, Calif.: University of California Press, 2012.In his Young People's Concert on American Music from 1958, Leonard Bernstein announced that "almost every country, or nation, has some kind of music that belongs to it, and sounds right and natural for its people."1 For Bernstein, the art music of the United States was a special case, a coming-of-age journey. American music only became "American," he claimed, when, at some point toward the middle of the twentieth century, composers moved away from imitating European models and shifted toward the nonself-conscious incorporation of vernacular musics into (European) genres like symphonies, operas, and chorale preludes.2 Eventually, he argued, American composers "just wrote music, and it came out American."3Bernstein's central question -as he put it, that of "what makes certain music seem to belong to America" (and not to a European country)4-has long dominated American music historiography. As Richard Crawford has written, "no fact about the writing of American music history is more characteristic than the looming presence of Europe."5 That European shadow has made a stubbornly central objective out of defining American music as a monolithic entity-what Bernstein called a "melting pot,"6 one in which striking differences are folded neatly under an overarching American umbrella.In her impressive book, Frontier Figures: American Music and the Mythology of the American West, Beth E. Levy continues to explore the questions that fascinated Bernstein, Crawford, and others. But she does so by refocusing the historiographical lens, zooming in on the diverse sounds often subsumed under the heading of American music. From its title alone, one might expect a study of how composers struck new paths to create a distinctly American (and thus non-European) sound by engaging with symbols and images of forests, prairies, and deserts. But rather than placing the work of composers such as Arthur Farwell, Virgil Thomson, Roy Harris, and Aaron Copland in the service of a narrative about American music as a unified concept, Levy unsettles that narrative. She chips away at what she calls a "scholarly preoccupation with the overarching category of 'Americanism'" and instead brings to light "specific decisions that composers have made about what could and should sound American (p. 17)."For Levy, the West, real and imagined, was a fruitful venue for such artistic decision making. In Frontier Figures, she investigates relationships between art music and America's frontiers from around 1900 to 1950. "Frontier" is, admittedly, a vague term, and one that points in many directions. Geographically, it is the constantly shifting area west of the Eastern Seaboard. Conceptually, as Levy writes, it reflects "new technology, political and demographic change, and large-scale shifts in aesthetic sensibility"-a set of changes crucial to understanding how music evolved in the first half of the twentieth century (p. 14). To explore the frontier, Levy generates pairings out of the composers named above and others, creating a series of case studies through which she examines a variety of compositions in the context of their connections to western history and mythology. With this case study model, Levy's work complements books like Denise von Glahn's The Sounds of Place: Music and the American Cultural Landscape and Carol J. Oja's Making Music Modem: New York in the 1920s-each of which also treats a series of connected figures.The first of Levy's "frontier figures," addressed in the book's first two parts, are Arthur Farwell and Charles Wakefield Cadman-two musicians who confronted Native American music with starkly different motivations and results. Farwell, today better known than Cadman, is also the more "serious" of the pair-the one for whom borrowings of components from American Indian cultures carried spiritual significance. …
History,Art