Racial Disparities in Older Adults with Schizophrenia: Demographic, Clinical, and Social/Psychosocial Factors
Moazam Afzal,James Lu,Carl I Cohen
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jagp.2024.01.131
2024-04-01
Abstract:Introduction African Americans (AA) are 2.5 times more likely than Caucasians (C) to be diagnosed with schizophrenia. In younger schizophrenia samples, significant racial differences have been found in discrimination, employment, educational attainment, residential status, number of children, income, marriage, social support, religiosity, treatment status, pharmacotherapy, quality of life, and PANSS scores. Despite the importance of the association of race with a variety of disparities in clinical and social outcomes, no comprehensive studies have been conducted examining racial differences in older adults with schizophrenia (OAS). We aimed to determine to what extent racial differences persist among persons with long-standing schizophrenia. Methods The sample comprised 221 persons in NYC (C:62%, AA:38%) aged 55 and older living in the community (mean age: 61 years) who had developed schizophrenia spectrum disorder before age 45 (mean age of onset: 31 years). The sample was stratified to capture persons living in various residential settings; 12%, 28%, and 60% were living with family, independently, or in supported housing, respectively. All were receiving some clinical care. Persons with substantial cognitive impairment were excluded. Based on previous studies of racial differences in younger schizophrenia populations, we conceptualized three broad categories: demographic, clinical, and social/psychosocial. We administered instruments that generated variables within the three categories: The Positive and Negative Syndrome Scale (PANSS), Center for Epidemiologic Studies-Depression Scale, Community Integration Scale, Quality of Life Index, Lifetime Traumatic Stress, Religiosity, Instrumental Activities of Daily Living, Ethnic Identity, Network Analysis Profile, Coping, Conflict Tactics, Financial Strain, Service Usage, and additional items about the characteristics of hallucinations and delusions. Results Initial bivariate analysis identified 11 significant variables that distinguished between the racial groups, and these were entered with 3 demographic covariates into a binary logistic regression analysis with race as the dependent variable. AAs were significantly more likely to live with family (OR=6.4), have children (OR=1.3), feel discriminated against (OR=1.3), and have a higher PANSS positive symptom score (OR=1.1), but less likely to report having a quick temper (OR=0.2). Among AAs living with family, 80% lived with children. A post-hoc regression analysis indicated that race (AA) and living with their family were independently (additively) associated with higher (β=.20) and lower (β=-.25) PANSS positive symptom scores, respectively, but their interactive effects were not significant (β=.04). Conclusions The findings showed surprisingly few racial differences among older persons with long-standing schizophrenia. Moreover, the principal racial differences were in social rather than clinical factors. Most notably, AAs were much more apt than Cs to live with family, especially children, although a majority of AAs lived in supported housing (54%). Hypothesized reasons for racial differences in family caregiving include cultural variations in kin responsibility, greater tolerance for abnormal behavior, and lower attributions of blame. Findings of discrimination and higher PANSS scores were similar to those found in younger samples. The higher PANSS scores may have reflected an unrecognized need for more treatment among AAs or rater racial biases in scoring the PANSS. Importantly, living with family was associated with lower PANSS scores. A limitation of this study is the cross-sectional nature of the data and the use of a convenience sample. Future research should include prospective designs and larger population-based samples.
psychiatry,geriatrics & gerontology,gerontology