Abstract:Cropland and pasture expansion continues to erase natural ecosystems at a staggering speed globally, notably in the tropics. Conventional policy approaches, usually focused on a particular land-use change driver (e.g., specific commodities) or individual regulations (e.g., the Amazon Soy Moratorium), have consistently failed to achieve sufficient or sustained results. The swift reversal of Brazil’s earlier success in reducing Amazon deforestation – now again accelerated – offers perhaps the most sobering illustration of that. Therefore, this article draws from scholarship on sustainability transitions to propose a more comprehensive systems view of unsustainable land-use patterns. We examine persistent tropical deforestation as a case of “lock-in,” using a transitions lens, and explore its constitutive elements. As a case study, we analyze the situation of Land Reform settlements in the Brazilian Amazon, where as much as one-third of that biome’s deforestation takes place. While subject to some specific factors, those places are also enmeshed in a broader setting that is common across the Brazilian Amazon’s deforestation frontier (e.g., infrastructure conditions, market demands, and sociocultural norms). Drawing from document analysis of Brazilian policies and fieldwork in three Land Reform settlements in Pará State, we expose multiple forms of techno-economic, institutional, and socio-cognitive lock-in that together drive deforestation systemically in those settlements. These drivers form a strongly consolidated socio-technical regime around large-scale agriculture that includes material and immaterial factors (e.g., cultural ones), a regime that not only resists change but also – like a vortex – pulls others into it. Escaping deforestation lock-in may thus require outside forces to help local actors destabilize and eventually replace this unsustainable land-use regime. International zero-deforestation efforts offer a starting point, but a transition requires moving beyond piecemeal, incremental change or end-of-pipe approaches and toward concerted, strategic action that addresses multiple of those regime elements in a coordinated way to replace it as a system. We argue that understanding deforestation lock-in is vital for tackling its worrisome persistence and that sustainability transitions theory offers an illuminating, but still underutilized, framework to analyze and eventually overcome unsustainable land use.

Synthesis: Land Transitions in the Tropics

Land Use Transitions: Progress, Challenges and Prospects

Mapping Land Use Land Cover Transitions at Different Spatiotemporal Scales in West Africa

Understanding deforestation lock-in: Insights from Land Reform settlements in the Brazilian Amazon

Global land use change, economic globalization, and the looming land scarcity

Grand Challenges in Understanding the Interplay of Climate and Land Changes

Integrated landscape approaches to managing social and environmental issues in the tropics: learning from the past to guide the future

The Global Climate of Land Politics

Land use transitions and land management: A mutual feedback perspective

Envisioning better forest transitions: A review of recent forest transition scholarship

Trends in Land-Use and Land-Cover Change: Key Insights for Managing the Atlantic Forest Transition

Land Use Change in the Continental United States: Are There Tipping Points?

Theory and the future of land-climate science

Land‐use choices: balancing human needs and ecosystem function

Critical transitions in rainfall manipulation experiments on grasslands

A meta‐analysis of tropical land‐use change effects on the soil microbiome: Emerging patterns and knowledge gaps

RANDOM AND SYSTEMATIC LAND USE/LAND COVER TRANSITIONS IN SEMI-ARID LANDSCAPES OF ETHIOPIAN CENTRAL RIFT VALLEY LAKES REGION (EAST AFRICA)

Theorizing land use transitions: A human geography perspective

Lessons and Challenges in Land Change Modeling Derived from Synthesis of Cross-Case Comparisons

Land-use and climate change risks in the Amazon and the need of a novel sustainable development paradigm

The social and ecological costs of reforestation. Territorialization and industrialization of land use accompany forest transitions in Southeast Asia