Effects of tensile strain and fluid flow on osteoarthritic human chondrocyte metabolism in vitro

Taro Mawatari,Derek P. Lindsey,Alex H.S. Harris,Stuart B. Goodman,William J. Maloney,Robert L. Smith
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/jor.21085
2010-01-08
Journal of Orthopaedic Research
Abstract:This study examined the hypothesis that tensile strain and fluid flow differentially influence osteoarthritic human chondrocyte metabolism. Primary high-density monolayer chondrocytes cultures were exposed to varying magnitudes of tensile strain and fluid-flow using a four-point bending system. Metabolic changes were quantified by real-time PCR measurement of aggrecan, IL-6, SOX-9, and type II collagen gene expression, and by determination of nitric oxide levels in the culture medium. A linear regression model was used to investigate the roles of strain, fluid flow, and their interaction on metabolic activity. Aggrecan, type II collagen, and SOX9 mRNA expression were negatively correlated to increases in applied strain and fluid flow. An effect of the strain on the induction of nitric oxide release and IL-6 gene expression varied by level of fluid flow (and visa versa). This interaction between strain and fluid flow was negative for nitric oxide and positive for IL-6. These results confirm that articular chondrocyte metabolism is responsive to tensile strain and fluid flow under in vitro loading conditions. Although the articular chondrocytes reacted to the mechanically applied stress, it was notable that there was a differential effect of tensile strain and fluid flow on anabolic and catabolic markers.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore how tensile strain and fluid flow affect the metabolism of human osteoarthritic chondrocytes separately and jointly. Specifically, the authors hypothesized that these two mechanical stimuli would affect the metabolic activities of chondrocytes in different ways, and this hypothesis was verified through experiments. ### Research Background Chondrocytes rely on appropriate and repetitive mechanical loading in daily activities to maintain the metabolism of their extracellular matrix. However, inappropriate joint loading (such as traumatic injury, limb immobilization, excessive body weight or skeletal malalignment, etc.) is associated with osteoarthritis (OA). These loads can lead to cell damage and matrix degradation, which in turn trigger inflammatory responses and other pathological changes. Although it is known that mechanical loading affects the function of chondrocytes, the specific mechanisms are still unclear. ### Research Objectives The main objective of this study was to explore the relative contributions of tensile strain and fluid flow to the metabolism of adult osteoarthritic chondrocytes. The research hypothesis was that chondrocytes would respond to tensile strain and fluid flow. To verify this hypothesis, the researchers adjusted the loading conditions by changing the substrate thickness, displacement and displacement rate, and measured the metabolic changes of chondrocytes under different loading conditions. ### Main Results 1. **Effects of Tensile Strain**: - Tensile strain increased NO release and IL - 6 gene expression. - Tensile strain decreased the expressions of aggrecan, type II collagen and SOX9 mRNA. 2. **Effects of Fluid Flow**: - Fluid flow also led to similar metabolic changes, especially in NO release and IL - 6 gene expression. 3. **Interaction**: - There was a significant interaction between tensile strain and fluid flow, especially in terms of NO release and IL - 6 gene expression. ### Conclusions This study shows that the metabolism of joint chondrocytes has a clear response to tensile strain and fluid flow, and these two mechanical stimuli have different effects on anabolic and catabolic markers. Understanding how these mechanical factors affect the metabolism of chondrocytes is of great significance for understanding the pathophysiological mechanisms of joint cartilage degeneration and developing corresponding intervention strategies. ### Formula Summary The linear regression models mentioned in the article are used to analyze the effects of strain, fluid flow and their interactions on metabolic activities: - Aggrecan production: \[ \text{Aggrecan production} = 1.01 - 0.0165\times\text{strain} - 0.232\times\text{disp rate} \] - Type II Collagen production: \[ \text{Type II Collagen production} = 1.01 - 0.0115\times\text{strain} - 0.301\times\text{disp rate} \] - SOX9 production: \[ \text{SOX9 production} = 1.00 - 0.000114\times\text{strain} - 0.156\times\text{disp rate} \] - NO production: \[ \text{NO production} = 7.00 + 0.0104\times\text{strain} + 21.1\times\text{disp rate}- 0.00922\times\text{strain}\times\text{disp rate} \] - IL - 6 production: \[ \text{IL - 6 production} = 0.0951 - 0.00141\times\text{strain} - 0.160\times\text{disp rate}+ 0.009191\times\text{strain}\times\text{disp rate} \] These formulas