Abstract:The North Central Education and Research Activity Committee (NCERA-59) was formed in 1952 to address how soil organic matter formation and management practices affect soil structure and productivity. It is in this capacity that we comment on the science supporting soil quality and associated soil health assessment for agricultural lands with the goal of hastening progress in this important field. Even though the suite of soil quality indicators being applied by U.S. soil health efforts closely mirrors the "minimum data set" we developed and recommended in the mid-1990s, we question whether the methods or means for their selection and development are sufficient to meet current and emerging soil health challenges. The rush to enshrine a standard suite of dated measures may be incompatible with longer-term goals. Legitimate study of soil health considers soil change accrued over years to decades that influence on- and off-site function. Tailoring of methods to local conditions is needed to effectively apply and interpret indicators for different soil resource regions and land uses. Adherence to a set suite of methods selected by subjective criteria should be avoided, particularly when we do not yet have adequate data or agreed upon interpretive frameworks for many so-called "Tier 1" biological indicators used in soil health assessment. While pooling data collected by producer-groups is one of the most exciting new trends in soil health, standardizing methods to meet broad inventory goals could compromise indicator use for site or application-specific problem solving. Changes in our nation's research landscape are shifting responsibility for soil stewardship from national and state government backed entities to public-private partnerships. As a result, it is critical to ensure that the data needed to assess soil health are generated by reproducible methods selected through a transparent process, and that data are readily available for public and private sector use. Appropriate methods for engagement need to be applied by public-private research partnerships as they establish and expand coordinated research enterprises that can deliver fact-based interpretation of soil quality indicators within the type of normative soil health framework conceived by USDA over 20 years ago. We look to existing examples as we consider how to put soil health information into the hands of practitioners in a manner that protects soils' services.

Soil Health Assessment of Agricultural Lands

Soil Health Assessment

Soil health assessment: Past accomplishments, current activities, and future opportunities

Soil Health Indicators: Methods and Applications

Soil Health Assessment of Forest Soils

Soil Health Assessment and Management Framework for Water-Limited Environments: Examples from the Great Plains of the USA

Soil Health Assessment and Management: Recent Development in Science and Practices

What We Talk about When We Talk about Soil Health

Rigorous, empirical, and quantitative: a proposed pipeline for soil health assessments

Soil health: looking for suitable indicators. What should be considered to assess the effects of use and management on soil health?

A database for global soil health assessment

Making soil health science practical: guiding research for agronomic and environmental benefits

An Open Soil Health Assessment Framework Facilitating Sustainable Soil Management

The soil health assessment protocol and evaluation applied to soil organic carbon

Introducing the North American project to evaluate soil health measurements

Developments in Agricultural Soil Quality and Health: Reflections by the Research Committee on Soil Organic Matter Management

A Review of Farmland Soil Health Assessment Methods: Current Status and a Novel Approach

The concept and future prospects of soil health

A new method for soil health assessment based on Analytic Hierarchy Process and meta-analysis

Soil health assessment: A critical review of current methodologies and a proposed new approach

A systematic benchmarking framework for future assessments of soil health: An example from Denmark