Abstract:To date, little research has explored differences between competitive and recreational youth sport contexts beyond descriptions of inherent features. The purpose of this exploratory study was to examine if differences existed between competitive and recreational youth sport on (a) observed quality delivery and (b) youth’s perceptions of basic psychological needs satisfaction and developmental experiences. Forty-six youth sport teams participated in the study from competitive ( n = 23) and recreational contexts. This study adopted a multi-method approach of self-report questionnaires and researcher observations. Teams agreed to be involved in observations ( n = 3), questionnaires ( n = 12) or both methods of data collection ( n = 31). Quality was assessed through 216 observations ( n = 134 competitive; M per team = 6.55), while basic psychological needs satisfaction and developmental experiences were examined through two questionnaires ( N = 413) completed at season end. Descriptive statistics and MANOVAs were calculated for all measures and associated subscales. Results revealed non-significant differences between competitive and recreational programs, despite high scores across the three measures. Significant effects are discussed related to of coaches’ years of coaching experience on program quality and ethnicity ratios on positive developmental experiences. Also discussed are notable effect sizes on opportunities for belonging and choice, where recreational contexts scored higher than competitive on each factor. Results offer understandings of how coach delivery can be enhanced, regardless of context, to optimize developmental benefits for youth. Implications are discussed for how future research can explore the complexities of different sport contexts, including associated coaching practices.

Quality at the Point of Service: Profiles of Practice in After-School Settings

After-School Programs and Children’s Mental Health: Organizational Social Context, Program Quality, and Children’s Social Behavior

Examination of the factorial structure of the positive youth development Program Quality Competency Questionnaire using responses from youth development professionals across the U.S.

Measuring Quality in Two Early Childhood Education Contexts: Centre-Based Childcare and Four-Year-Old Preschool

Preschool Teachers’ Professional Background, Process Quality, and Job Attitudes: A Person-Centered Approach

A Profile Approach to Child Care Quality, Quantity, and Type of Setting: Parent Selection of Infant Child Care Arrangements

Interactional quality in middle schools: Latent profiles and their associations with teacher, classroom, and school compositional factors

Does context matter? Unpacking differences in program quality and developmental experiences across competitive and recreational youth sport

Subjective Outcome Evaluation of a Positive Youth Development Program in Mainland China

Towards the development of a quality youth sport experience measure: Understanding participant and stakeholder perspectives

A mixed-methods investigation of early childhood professional development for providers and recipients in the United States

A new look at teacher interactional quality: Profiles of individual teacher–child relationship and classroom teaching quality among Head Start students

Profiles of teacher-child interaction quality in groups of 3-year-old children in Quebec and France

The Quality of Teacher–Child Interactions during the Enactment of Playful Science Games in Preschool

Physical Activity-Related Practices and Psychosocial Factors of Childcare Educators: A Latent Profile Analysis

An Observation Procedure for Assessing Children's Social Behaviours in Free Play Settings

Defining early education quality using CLASS-observed teacher-student interaction

Quality Indicators for Family Support Services and Their Relationship to Organizational Social Context

Would We Know It If We Saw It? Assessing Quality of Care in Group Homes for Youth

Child-care quality and children's social development.

Promoting a Person-Centered Approach to Strengthening Early Childhood Practices that Support Social-Emotional Development