Comparison of Dural Graft Types and Graft Fixation Methods in Chiari Malformation Type I Decompression Surgery
Zuli Hu,Gang Liao,Yuzhao Lu,Chunliang Wang,Jinhong Mei
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.wneu.2022.04.127
IF: 2.21
2022-01-01
World Neurosurgery
Abstract:OBJECTIVE: Suboccipital decompression with duraplasty is being increasingly accepted for treating patients with Chiari malformation type 1 (CM -1). To date, the optimal duraplasty for CM -I has not been delineated, This study aims to compare the clinical and radiologic effects of duraplasty performed using 2 types of grafts and 2 graft fixation methods in 3 combinations. METHODS: In this retrospective study, 84 consecutive decompressions with duraplasty were analyzed. Two types of grafts (nonautologous [Non -Auto G], 90.5% and autologous [Auto G], 9.5%) and 2 graft fixations (suturing [S], 31.0%; and suturing plus gluing [S G], 69,0%) were used in 3 different combinations: Non -Auto G S: 31.0%, Non -Auto G S G: 59.5%, and Auto G S G: 9.5%. All patients were followed up for 3 months. Clinical results were evaluated using the Gestalt scale, and syringoiriyelia results were evaluated using magnetic resonance imaging. RESULTS: According to the Gestalt scale, 82.1% of the patients showed improvement 3 months post operation, and the improvement was not related to the type of graft (P 0.90), fixation (P = 0.90), or duraplasty (P = 0.81), Decreased syringomyelia was observed in 76.4% of the patients. It was not associated with the graft (P = 0.53), fixation (P = 0.72), or duraplasty (P = 0.80). Meningitis occurred in the Auto G S G, Non -Auto G S G and Non Auto G S groups (25%, 48%, and 23.1%, respectively, P = 0.30), and their formations were not related to the k graft type (P = 0.57) or fixation (P = 0.19). CONCLUSIONS: Autologous and nonautologous dural grafts can be performed using either sutures or sutures plus glue, as both result in similar outcomes.