‘Why did they build this hill so steep?’: Problems of assessing primary children's understanding of physical landscape features in the context of the UK national curriculum

Doug Harwood,Pamela Jackson
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/10382046.1993.9964911
1993-08-01
International Research in Geographical and Environmental Education
Abstract:Despite the fact that physical landscape concepts are fundamental to an understanding of geography, the new National Curriculum for English schools fails to develop this area in a systematic and progressive way. In this research, a small group of 9–11 year‐olds take part in an in‐depth assessment of their understanding of nine common vernacular physical landscape features. The results of three main methods of individual assessment are compared (oral interview, picture recognition and picture drawing). Many significant misconceptions are revealed, and it emerges that children perform differently according to the mode of assessment used. The dangers of using a single, narrowly‐focused assessment strategy within the National Curriculum is thereby exposed. There is a correlation between the level of understanding and children's direct experience of the features. A sequential programme for the development of physical landscape concepts is offered and some children's compensatory need for direct and simulated experience is emphasised.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?