Abstract:Background: A growing interest in engaging communities in the development of health care services and communities has not automatically led to progress or consensus as to how to engage communities successfully, despite the evidence base showing how to leverage enablers and alleviate barriers. Objective: To bridge the gap between the evidence base and which community engagement (CE) approaches have actually been applied in practice over time, this study aims to investigate how CE approaches have changed over the past 4 years in 6 different regions in the Netherlands and citizens' and professionals' experiences underlying these changes. Methods: For the last stage of a multiple case study following the development of CE approaches in 6 different regions in the Netherlands, a realist qualitative case study was conducted. To investigate how CE approaches had changed over the past 4 years, data from the entire 4 years of the study were used, including documents, interview transcripts, and observations. To examine citizens' and professionals' experiences underlying these changes, new interviews were conducted. The latest interview results were discussed with a panel to ensure the results had face validity. Results: The regions had implemented different types of CE approaches over the past 4 years and were adapting these approaches over time. Many of the (remaining) approaches may be operating on a smaller scale. The study identified the following overarching themes along which CE had been adapted: fewer region-wide approaches and more community-focused approaches, more focus on building relationships with (already engaged) citizens and community-led initiatives, and more focus on practical and tangible health promotion and social cohesion activities and less focus on complex "abstract" programs. The study identified a further 4 overarching themes highlighting citizens' and professionals' experiences underlying these changes in the CE approaches: a lack of engagement environment, need for facilitative leadership from organizations, need for a clear and shared vision underscoring the importance of CE, and misalignment between citizens' and professionals' perspectives and motivations for CE. All participants had experienced the engagement environment as insufficient. To support CE, professionals experienced the need to develop and receive more facilitative leadership and to develop approaches better equipped to involve citizens in the decision-making process. Citizens experienced the need to better align citizens' and professionals' motivations and aims for CE approaches and to receive longer-term financial support for their community-led initiatives. Conclusions: This study suggests that CE has not yet been embedded within organizational cultures. This has arguably meant that the (remaining) CE approaches are operating on a smaller scale. To enable the further development of CE approaches, an investment in the engagement environment and a shared vision is required. Only then could CE within the regions move beyond the more seemingly smaller-scale CE approaches.

“What Was That Word? It’s Part of Ensuring Its Future Existence” Exploring Engagement Collectives at the European Commission’s Joint Research Centre

Envisioning Collaborative Futures: Advancing the Frontiers of Embedded Research

From Deliberation to Production: Public Participation in Science and Technology Policies of the European Commission (1998–2019)

The European Union's Citizenship Regime. Creating Norms and Building Practices

How Do Frontline Civil Servants Engage the Public? Practices, Embedded Agency, and Bricolage

Engagement in European social dialogue: an investigation into the role of social partner structural capacity

Citizen Science in European Research Infrastructures

Engagement in the digital age: Understanding "what works" for participatory technologies in environmental decision-making

Achieving successful community engagement: a rapid realist review

European regional policy making: A challenge for our collective intelligence

Generating employee engagement in a public–private partnership: management communication activities and employee experiences

Understanding cultural participation through participation – inventiveness, multivalence and epistemic modernisation

The role of experience and diversity on research consortia' performance: an exploratory approach

Public Participation and Scientific Citizenship in the Science Museum in London: Visitors’ Perceptions of the Museum as a Broker

Agenda‐setting under pressure: Does domestic politics influence the European Commission?

Constraints and Affordances of Online Engagement With Scientific Information-A Literature Review

Engagement markers in research project websites: Promoting interactivity and dialogicity

Soft Power and Hard Measures: Large-Scale Assessment, Citizenship and the European Union

Tracking the Development of Community Engagement Over Time: Realist Qualitative Study

Enabling the Digital Democratic Revival: A Research Program for Digital Democracy