Information Metacognition: A Course Case Study
L. Farmer
2003-09-22
Abstract:Abstract LI 500 Foundations of Information was a new course designed in two formats: an online course using BlackBoard and a largely face-to-face course. The two options provide choice for students as well as a basis for evaluating the effect of delivery on student achievement and satisfaction. Background As the coordinator of the Library Media Teacher (LMT) program at California State University Long Beach (CSULB) developed a master's degree program, I created an introductory course to provide the theoretical underpinnings of the profession. This course, LI 500 Foundations of Information, provides a foundation for library and information science, and underlies the societal context of information and technology. In the process of designing the course, I wanted to examine the impact of delivery mode, comparing face-to-face delivery (with intervening online activity) and a totally online environment. The delivery mode of the course addressed the need to incorporate technology to optimize access to relevant resources (many of which in information science occur only in electronic form) as well as foster telecommunications and collaboration. It also addressed the need for alternative means to reach students with transportation or time constraints. Additionally, by providing two delivery methods for the same section of the same course, it was thought that students would have greater choice in their education. Additionally, this commingling of course delivery methods is apparently unusual; most courses have separate sections for face-to-face and online learners. (Boettcher 2001; Leh 2002; Stair 1997). The educational model that appears to best accommodate student choice in varying delivery methods is facilitation, which establishes a resource-rich learning environment and focuses on optimizing group dynamics as students meet desired outcomes (Schwartz 1994); its technology-based counterpart has been labeled as e-moderation by Salmon (2000). (This approach is used mainly in adult training and workplace learning where students are more self-directed and purposeful. (Smith 2003) In brief, systematic analysis of the impact of computer-enhanced/blended (i.e., face-to-face activities supplemented with online assignments) and online delivery modes is lacking in the professional literature, and this project provides a solid case study of that issue. As this new course was being developed, it provided an optimal situation for analyzing the effects of course delivery. As such, the following aspects were noted: (1) Two versions of LI 500 were developed and offered: a blended delivery and a completely online delivery. (2) Students could choose a blended delivery or online delivery of the same class: LI 500 (3) The coordinator measured, analyzed and drew conclusions about the impact of delivery mode (blended vs. online) of LI500 on student achievement and satisfaction; and on faculty instruction and satisfaction. To evaluate the project's effectiveness, a number of assessment measurements were utilized: * Database of students who enroll in course: quantity, demographics, majors, GPA, course grade * Electronic tracking of Blackboard use * Collection of representative student work demonstrating information literacy competence * Student self-assessment of information literacy skills based on existing rubrics. The assessment results can help determine the viability of other courses being offered in these delivery modes, help refine course design, and also determine the course's adoption by other programs. Demographics Nine students enrolled in LIT500 Foundations of Information: two online and seven face-to-face. One online student was male; all the others were female. The male student was under 30 years old. Most of the other students were in their forties. Seven students worked as the LMT in their school; one other (a female who took the course online) was a substitute teacher, and the other was an English high school teacher. …
Psychology,Education