Speculating about the migration crisis: acting from above and below on the Canary Islands route
Ignacio Fradejas-GarcíaKristín Loftsdóttira Departament of Sociology,University of Oviedo,Oviedo,Spainb Department of Anthropology,School of Social Sciences,University of Iceland,Reykjavik,IcelandIgnacio Fradejas-García works as Assistant Professor in the Sociology Departament at the University of Oviedo (Spain). He has been a postdoctoral researcher at the University of Iceland and at the Autonomous University of Barcelona. With extensive fieldwork experience in Gambia,Chile,Morocco,Haiti,DR Congo,Turkey,Romania and Spain,his lines of research revolve around six main axes: humanitarianism and borders,(im)mobilities and migrations,informality,networks,sports,and methodology. His work has been published in peer-reviewed journals such as Social Anthropology (2019),Mobilities (2019),Migration Letters (2021),Social Inclusion (2021),Mortality (2022),Politics and Governance (2022) and Globalizations (2023).Kristín Loftsdóttir is Professor of Anthropology at the University of Iceland. Her research has focused on notions of exceptionalism,the racialisation of mobility,racism,gender,crisis,globalisation,nationalism,migration and postcolonial Europe. She is the author of Crisis and Coloniality at Europe's Margins: Creating Exotic Iceland (Routledge,2019) and We Are All African Here: Race,Mobilities and West Africans in Europe (2021),and co-author of Exceptionalism (Routledge,2021). She is also co-editor of Whiteness and Postcolonialism in the Nordic Region: Exceptionalism,Migrant Others and National Identities (Routledge,2012),Crisis in the Nordic Nations and Beyond: At the Intersection of Environment,Finance and Multiculturalism (Routledge,2014),and Messy Europe: Crisis,Race and the Nation State in a Postcolonial World (2018). She is currently Principal Investigator of the CERM (Creating Europe through Racialized Mobilities) project.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/01436597.2024.2346623
2024-05-15
Third World Quarterly
Abstract:In Europe, increased precarity characterises the lives of many people, making crisis-talk especially appealing as a framing mechanism to naturalise anti-migration policies within the EU. In 2020–2021, the EU and the Spanish government proclaimed a migration crisis and immobilised in dehumanising conditions a few thousand African migrants who had just arrived in the Canary Islands. This action was facilitated by narratives of migrant invasion and the view of Europe as a space of formality. This article asks what kinds of speculation the proclamation of a migration crises creates and who is doing the speculating. We stress that the term 'speculation' is based strongly on temporalities involving the creation of value by future predictions in uncertain circumstances. Using the Canary Islands as an example, we use this future-oriented understanding of speculation to emphasise that different actors, and not only financial ones, also imagine and act on the future as a sort of infraspeculation . While not losing sight of how the latter differs from financial speculation, it is important to highlight the diverse forms of agency in relation to migration within a quite complex changing policy and crisis-management environment.
development studies