Factors Predicting Mental Health Among Women in Low-Income Communities of a Changing Society: A Mixed-Methods Study
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/IJWH.S397845
2023-03-17
Abstract:Lisa R Roberts, 1 Vathsala Sadan, 2 Rajeswari Siva, 2 Manoranjitham Sathiyaseelan, 2 Sara Emma Rosalind, 2 Prema Suresh, 2 Susanne B Montgomery 3 1 Loma Linda University School of Nursing, Loma Linda, CA, USA; 2 Christian Medical College-Vellore, College of Nursing, Vellore, Tamil Nadu, India; 3 Loma Linda University School of Behavioral Health, Loma Linda, CA, USA Correspondence: Lisa R Roberts, Loma Linda University School of Nursing, 11262 Campus Street, Loma Linda, CA, 92350, USA, Tel +1 909 558 1000, Fax +1 909 558 0719, Email Purpose: To explore women's mental health in India's rapidly changing society. Participants and Methods: A convenience sample of low-income women (N = 286) in a medium-sized city in South-India participated in a mixed-methods, exploratory study in 2022. Institutional Review Board (IRB) approval was received from Loma Linda University in the US, and Christian Medical College-Vellore in India, in accordance with the declaration of Helsinki, prior to data collection. All study materials were forward and back translated for Tamil, the local language. Phase 1(n = 25) involved audio recorded key-informant interviews and focus groups. Verbatim transcripts were inductively coded, and emerging themes identified. Phase 2 (n = 261) entailed a quantitative survey including demographics, health history, and validated scales measuring mental health symptoms, coping strategies, social support, living situation, and life satisfaction. Data collectors were gender and language matched, research trained, community health nurses. Results: Qualitative themes included: 1) benefits of living in the city, 2) double duty for women doing household work and paid work, 3) challenges of living in the urban environment, 4) advantages of living in the village, 5) struggles associated with village life. Quantitative results: the average Hopkins Symptoms Checklist (HSCL) score of 1.82 ( SD = 0.70) exceeded the 1.65 cut-off score for anxiety and depression symptomology. Among participants with elevated HSCL scores (n = 129) the average was markedly elevated ( M = 2.39, SD = 0.56). These women were more likely to rely on wishful thinking, religious coping, and reported more post-migration living difficulties, less social support, and less satisfaction with life. Regression analysis further explored variables associated with participant HSCL scores. Conclusion: In this sample of low-income urban-dwelling women depression and anxiety symptomology was elevated. Given the limited mental health workforce and cultural stigmatization of mental health issues, further attention is required. Keywords: India, urban women, post-migration, social support, coping Globalization and urbanization have produced mixed results with respect to benefits and risks for the average Indian. The positive effects include economic change, tremendous growth, and a promise of a better life for the middle-class segment of Indian society. With these changes, women are experiencing transition in terms of work expectations, family life, and environment. 1,2 The negative effects of globalization and urbanization affect low-income persons disproportionately and include expansion of slums and shifting role expectations to survive. As a result, globalization and urbanization are known to affect physical and mental health negatively, often resulting in decreased psychological security, and increased isolation and lack of support. 2–4 However, there is more to know about India than just its rate of globalization and urbanization. Within Indian communities, social support networks, culture, customs, traditions, and beliefs contribute to individuals' experiences of tensions inherent in being a woman in today's Indian society. 5 Race, class, and gender (intersectional tensions) influence health in addition to common social determinants of health (economic and physical environments), and are important to understanding women's health and health disparities in the Indian context. 6,7 See Figure 1. Figure 1 Intersectional tensions and social determinants of health influencing women's health. India is vastly diverse in terms of culture and women's status, exemplified by the juxtaposition of its patriarchal society and traditional social norms limiting women's autonomy, and its history of powerful women in leadership. 8–13 Nevertheless, gendered roles and social expectations for women continue to include the expectation of childbearing and the importance of producing sons. 8,14,15 As part of these pressures, women often experience reproductive coercion, a form of domestic violen -Abstract Truncated-
obstetrics & gynecology