Abstract:Context. The most recent minimum of solar activity was deeper and longer than the previous two minima as indicated by different proxies of solar activity. This is also true for the total solar irradiance (TSI) according to the PMOD composite. Aims. The apparently unusual behaviour of the TSI has been interpreted as evidence against solar surface magnetism as the main driver of the secular change in the TSI. We test claims that the evolution of the solar surface magnetic field does not reproduce the observed TSI in cycle 23. Methods. We use sensitive, 60-min averaged MDI magnetograms and quasi-simultaneous continuum images as an input to our SATIRE-S model and calculate the TSI variation over cycle 23, sampled roughly every two weeks. The computed TSI is then compared with the PMOD composite of TSI measurements and with the data from two individual instruments, SORCE/TIM and UARS/ACRIM II, that monitored the TSI during the declining phase of cycle 23 and over the previous minimum in 1996, respectively. Results. Excellent agreement is found between the trends shown by the model and almost all sets of measurements. The only exception is the early, i.e. 1996 to 1998, PMOD data. Whereas the agreement between the model and the PMOD composite over the period 1999–2009 is almost perfect, the modelled TSI shows a steeper increase between 1996 and 1999 than implied by the PMOD composite. On the other hand, the steeper trend in the model agrees remarkably well with the ACRIM II data. A closer look at the VIRGO data, which are the basis of the PMOD composite after 1996, reveals that only one of the two VIRGO instruments, the PMO6V, shows the shallower trend present in the composite, whereas the DIARAD measurements indicate a steeper trend. Conclusions. Based on these results, we conclude that (1) the sensitivity changes of the PMO6V radiometers within VIRGO during the first two years have very likely not been correctly evaluated; and that (2) the TSI variations over cycle 23 and the change in the TSI levels between the minima in 1996 and 2008 are consistent with the solar surface magnetism mechanism.

THE SUN'S SMALL-SCALE MAGNETIC ELEMENTS IN SOLAR CYCLE 23

Magnetic flux structuring of the quiet Sun internetwork. Center-to-limb analysis of solar-cycle variations

Solar Cycle Variation in the Properties of Photospheric Magnetic Concentrations

The solar meridional circulation and sunspot cycle variability

Global solar photospheric and coronal magnetic field over activity cycles 21–25

Solar-cycle and Latitude Variations in the Internetwork Magnetism

Cyclic variations in the main components of the solar large-scale magnetic field

The Sun's Magnetic Power Spectra over Two Solar Cycles. II. Cycle Dependence of Active Regions, a Magnetic Network, and Their Relation

Brightness of Solar Magnetic Elements as a Function of Magnetic Flux at High Spatial Resolution

The Sun's Magnetic Power Spectra over Two Solar Cycles. \uppercase\expandafter{\romannumeral2}. Cycle Dependence of Active Region, Magnetic Network, and Their Relation

Nonextensivity in the solar magnetic activity during the increasing phase of solar Cycle 23

The total solar irradiance, UV emission and magnetic flux during the last solar cycle minimum

Dynamics of the photosphere along the solar cycle from SDO/HMI

Basal magnetic flux and the local solar dynamo

Solar Cycle Variation of 0.3-1.29 MeV/nucleon Heavy Ion Composition during Quiet Times near 1 AU in Solar Cycles 23 and 24

Solar internetwork magnetic fields: Statistical comparison between observations and MHD simulations

The Sun's Magnetic Power Spectra Over Two Solar Cycles. I. Calibration Between SDO/HMI And SOHO/MDI Magnetograms

Study on the relation of the solar coronal rotation with magnetic field structures

Evolution of solar wind sources and coronal rotation driven by the cyclic variation of the Sun's large-scale magnetic field

Solar total irradiance in cycle 23

Comparison of I-ICME and M-ICME Fittings and in Situ Observation Parameters for Solar Cycles 23 and 24 and Their Influence on Geoeffectiveness