Abstract:Modigliani and Miller (M&M) proposed that investors forgo dividends, leaving the money available for reinvestment as retained earnings. This recommendation takes two parts: Proposition III, i.e., a dividend has no impact on market value, and Proposition IV, i.e., that financial policy is of no consequence to investors, and retention or distribution of earnings is purely a management decision (Stiglitz, 1974). Ross & Westerfeld (Ross, Westerfield, & Jaffe, 2010) amplify the M&M proposal by saying that companies should not give up projects that are net present value (NPV)-positive in order to distribute dividends. The purpose of this paper is to analyze non-dividend-distributing companies for positive NPV. I picked companies from the Standard and Poor’s 500 Index and studied their earnings for Internal Rate of Return (IRR) and NPV by using probability indices over the course of ten-year periods. The null hypothesis is that Modigliani and Miller were correct and “the division of the stream between cash dividends and retained earnings in any period is a mere detail.” The conclusion of the paper, however, is that in most cases companies are not successful in generating consistent IRR, or positive Profitability Index, and the null hypothesis should therefore be rejected. The paper also tabulates the assumptions needed for the Dividend Irrelevancy theory to function as published by M&M over 30 years ago. It makes the theory appear more mathematical fata morgana than applied finance. I would like to thank my colleague Jerome Balsam for his suggestions. The conclusion of the paper are, of course my own.

Do fair value adjustments influence dividend policy?

The Effect of Fair Value Adjustments on Dividend Policy Under Mandatory International Financial Reporting Standards Adoption: Australian Evidence

(Un)intended Consequences of a Mandatory Dividend Payout Regulation for Earnings Management: Evidence From a Natural Experiment:

Stock Liquidity and Dividend Policy: Dividend Policy Changes Following an Exogenous Liquidity Shock

The Fluctuation of Stock Prices:Is it Risk or Value?

Does Stock Market Liquidity Affect Dividends?

Dividend Taxes, Investor Horizon, and Idiosyncratic Volatility

Asymmetric Cost Behavior and Dividend Policy

Stock Dividend and Analyst Optimistic Bias in Earnings Forecast

Dividend Volatility and Asset Prices: A Loss Aversion/Narrow Framing Approach

An Empirical Study of the Impact of Cash Flow Uncertainty on Dividend Policy

The Cash-Flow Permanence and Information Content of Dividend Increases Versus Repurchases

The Influence of Fair Value Measurement on the Pledge of Overconfident Major Shareholders Based on Multiple Regression and Fisher Test.

Do fair value measurements affect accounting-based earnings quality? A literature review with a focus on corporate governance as moderator

Are Reinvested Earnings a Substitute for Dividends?

The Impact of Dividend Policies and Financing Strategies on the Speed of Firms’ Capital Structure Adjustment

The impact of R&D intensity, financial constraints, and dividend payout policy on firm value

Surprise! Higher Dividends = Higher Earnings Growth

Fair Value Accounting and Market Volatility

Dividend Smoothing and Financial Transparency

Dividend Policy and Cash-Flow Uncertainty