Land, Water, and Food: Eco-cosmopolitan Feminist Praxis in Sabiha Sumar's Khamosh Pani

Shazia Rahman
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/17524032.2011.562521
2011-05-19
Environmental Communication
Abstract:In an attempt to address the violence against women in South Asia while also keeping the environment in mind, I argue that Sabiha Sumar's film Khamosh Pani resists both religious nationalism and global capitalism through an eco-cosmopolitan feminist stance that is grounded in a materiality of place signified by land, water, and food. In my reading, the eco-cosmopolitan feminism of this film critiques patriarchy in the Punjab across the border with India and, simultaneously, remains locally grounded in that place with its local language, customs, and religious practices. As the history of the partition of British India has shown, when fathers and brothers forced their women to commit suicide by jumping in the village well to avoid rape, they simultaneously poisoned the well-water as the men migrated across the border. Violence against women was also violence against the waters of the Punjab. After showing how the film is feminist, I discuss how it draws attention to the materiality of the Pakistani Punjab on eco-cosmopolitan feminist terms. Specifically, I demonstrate that portrayals of land, water, and food present crucial tensions between patriarchal and nationalist Islamization and the resistance of Pakistan's women to these forces. An eco-cosmopolitan feminist reading of this film is particularly significant at this time given the continued violence against women in Punjab in the name of honor.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?